Matching
|
Allows intuitive analysis and transparent presentation of covariate balance
Removes covariate imbalance more effectively (less bias) than other stratification or covariate adjustment
Does not require specification of the PS-outcome association
|
|
Weighting
|
Can be extended to account for time-dependent confounding and censoring
Removes covariate imbalance more effectively (less bias) than other stratification or covariate adjustment
Does not require specification of the PS-outcome association
Analyzes study population within range of common support
|
May be subject to the influence of few patients with extreme weights
PS model misspecification can result in extreme weights.
Subject to residual and unmeasured confounding
|
Stratification
|
Allows relatively straightforward analysis and transparent presentation of covariate balance for each stratum
Does not require specification of the PS-outcome association
Analyzes study population within range of common support
|
In the presence of non-uniform treatment effects across strata, a single summary estimate is not meaningful.
Subject to residual and unmeasured confounding
|
Covariate
Adjustment
|
|
Requires specification of the PS-outcome association; if misspecified, the estimated effect can be biased.
Does not allow transparent assessment of covariate balance
Subject to residual and unmeasured confounding
Due to these limitations, this method is no longer considered a best practice.
|