Skip to main content
. 2016 Apr 27;37(17):1589–1600. doi: 10.1002/jcc.24375

Table 3.

NBB4, ssEA, ssEAc, and ssPA results for the eight transformations (ΔΔG bind or ΔΔG MM→QM in kJ/mol).

Quantity ΔΔG bind ΔΔG MM→QM ΔΔG bind w max
Method NBB4 ssEA ssEAc ssPA ssEAc ssEA
Averaging all 15 indep all all 15 indep all 15 indep all
MeBz→Bz −2.4±4.1 −1.1±2.9 −16.7±4.1 −13.8±1.0 −13.7±1.3 −11.6±0.16 3.1±1.3 0.76
EtBz→MeBz −1.5±4.0 −4.5±3.2 −5.0±3.9 0.6±1.0 0.5±1.0 −2.8±0.17 4.4±1.0 0.87
pClBz→Bz 11.4±3.9 13.0±2.8 −10.7±4.0 −11.8±1.0 −11.8±1.0 −5.9±0.17 9.5±1.0 0.85
mClBz→Bz 31.9±7.2 9.6±3.8 11.9±4.9 −2.4±1.0 −2.4±1.0 −2.2±0.17 5.0±1.0 0.90
Hx→Bz 3.9±6.2 −3.7±2.2 −14.3±6.3 −15.5±1.0 −15.6±1.1 −29.9±0.17 3.5±1.1 0.92
MeHx→Hx −1.4±5.1 5.6±2.9 −17.5±5.4 −10.0±0.9 −9.8±1.1 −3.8±0.16 6.8±1.1 0.96
Hx→Pen −1.7±2.8 −2.4±3.3 −7.8±2.9 −8.4±1.0 −8.3±1.0 −4.5±0.16 0.5±1.0 0.55
Hep→Hx 17.4±2.2 11.1±2.8 9.3±2.2 −0.1±0.9 −0.2±0.9 −0.5±0.16 8.1±0.9 0.36

Results are shown for either all 60,000 snapshots in a single calculation with standard errors obtained with bootstrapping (all) or as the average over 15 independent simulations with 4000 snapshots each, obtaining standard errors from the standard deviation over these 15 results, divided by 15 (15 indep). In the last column, w max is given for the ssEA–all calculation.