Skip to main content
. 2016 Oct 28;11(10):e0164209. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0164209

Table 2. Estimated average of yearly carbon (C) inputsa,b,c to each crop phase (g C m-2) and analysisd,e,f,g.

Crop phase System Aboveground biomass C Root biomass C Est. root exudates Manure Total C inputs
Average of all crop years 2 293.1 (93.1) a 13.15 (3.37) a 12.56 (4.14) A 319.2 (97.2) a
3 304.9 (97.9) a 11.18 (2.59) a 9.96 (3.25) A 46.1 (68.0) a 372.6 (166.6) a
4 175.8 (178.6) a 12.56 (6.80) a 11.89 (4.47) A 34.6 (61.8) b 235.6 (231.2) b
Corn 2 374.6 (38.8) a* 14.7 (3.53) a 14.72 (3.71) A 404.5 (40.3) b
3 428 (50.2) a* 12.43 (3.01) a 13.24 (3.09) A 138.2 (0.0) 592.8 (48.9) a
4 413.5 (51.8) a 12.78 (4.74) a 12.00 (6.68) A 138.2 (0.0) 577.6 (57.6) a
Mean 405.4 (49.0) A 13.30 (3.61) AB 13.32 (4.46) A 92.2 (68.1) 525.0 (99.9) A
Soy 2 211.5 (32.9) b 11.59 (2.67) a 10.39 (3.69) A 233.9 (33.8) b*
3 258.4 (28.4) a 10.30 (3.43) a 8.85 (2.11) A 277.8 (31.8) ab*
4 260.4 (22.2) a 12.94 (2.56) a 10.18 (4.14) A 283.8 (22.0) a
Mean 243.4 (34.4) B 11.61 (2.83) AB 9.81 (3.18) A 265.2 (35.2) B
Oat/legume 3 228.5 (24.6) a 10.80 (0.74) a 7.80 (1.60) A 247.2 (23.5) a
4 0.0 (0.0) b 6.31 (3.49) a 12.78 (2.81) A 19.5 (3.4) b
Mean 114.3 (123.7) C 8.56 (3.11) B 10.29 (3.40) A 133.4 (123.0) C
Alfalfa 4 29.4 (4.5) 18.20 (9.18) 12.61 (4.95) A 61.6 (7.2)
Mean 29.4 (4.5) D 18.20 (9.18) A 12.61 (4.95) A 97.5 (7.2) C

a C from stover measured in fall 2009

b C measured in roots collected in fall 2009.

c Sum of aboveground and root biomass C from the previous crop, manure C incorporated to the crop, if any, and root exudate C calculated after [45] as 0.65*summer root C

d Standard deviations are in parenthesis.

e Different lowercase letters represent differences between systems in a specified crop that were significant at p<0.05

f Asterisks * represent differences between systems in a specified crop that were significant at p<0.10.

g Different uppercase letters represent differences that were significant at p<0.05 between values for each crop averaged over all rotations and both depths.