Table 3.
Comparison of state of the art works. SPS, samples per second; ESB, Enhanced ShockBurst.
| This Work | Neurochip-2 | WIMAGINE | PennBMBI | W-HERBS | Nguyen | Angotzi | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (2015) | (2011) [9] | (2015) [8] | (2015) [11] | (2011) [7] | (2014) [10] | (2014) [12] | |
| Recording channel | 32 unipolar/bipolar | 3 unipolar/bipolar | 64 | 4 | 64×2 | 32 | 8 |
| Gain | 192 | 1000 or 5000 | 1000 | 200 | 40–80 dB | 200 | - |
| ADC resolution | 16 bits | 8 bits | 12 bits | 12bits | 12 bits | 16 bits | 8 bits |
| Sampling rate | 800 SPS/channel up to 30 kSPS/channel | 256 SPS | 1 kSPS | 21 kSPS | 1 kSPS | 400 kSPS 12.5 kSPS/channel |
15 kSPS/channel |
| Bandwidth | 0.1–20 kHz | 10 Hz–7.5 Hz | 0.5 Hz–400 Hz | 0.05 Hz–6 kHz | 0.1 Hz–1 kHz | 0.2 Hz–5 kHz | 1 Hz–10 kHz |
| Communication | 2.4 GHz RF communication link with μESB protocol | Serial cable/ infrared data link | Proprietary UHF link in MICS band | 2.4 GHz RF communication link | Bluetooth | Wired | 2.4 GHz ISM band |
| Power supply | Rechargeable 3.7 V battery | 1 or 2 rechargeable 3.6 V battery | Inductive link | Rechargeable 3.7 V battery | Polymer Lithium ion 3.7 V battery | 5 V USB | 3.7 V 700 mAh battery |
| Power consumption | 4.22–15.4 mA | 284–420 mW | 75 mW w/o charging 350 mW w/ charging |
7.3 mA transmit for sensor node only | 4.9 mW (AFE) 300 mW (wireless) |
- | - |
| Battery charging | Wireless ultrasonic charging | - | - | - | Wireless charging coil 4 W at distance 38 mm | - | - |
| Size | 35 mm in diameter 10 mm in thickness |
63×63×30 mm | 50 mm in diameter 12.54 mm in thickness antenna:10 cm |
56×36×13 mm + 43×27×8 mm + 31×13×8 mm | 20×30×2.5 mm + 60×60×8 mm + 40 mm in diameter 8 mm in thickness |
29.5×43.4 mm | - |
| Stimulation channel | 4 unipolar/bipolar | 3 unipolar/bipolar | - | 2 | - | 1 optical stimuli | 8 bipolar |
| Stimulation voltage | 20 V | ±15 V (normal) ±50 V (high V) |
- | ±12 V | - | - | ±9 V |
| current intensity | 40 A | 10–200 A current pulse or 0.5–5 mA | - | 0–1 mA | - | - | 300 A |
| Pulse width | 1 us minimum | 0.2 ms, 0.6 ms | - | 200 s | - | - | - |
| Pulse frequency | 250 Hz | 1/min or 1/10 min | - | - | - | - | - |