Table 1. Interactive effects of N supply and water status on gas exchange and water use efficiency in two varieties of wheat.
Treatment | Pn [μmol (CO2 m-2s-1)] | E [mmol (H2O m-2s-1)] | Gs [mol (H2O m-2s-1)] | Ci [μmol (CO2) mol-1] | WUE [μmol(CO2)mol(H2O)-1] | WUEi [μmol(CO2)mol(H2O)-1] | Ls | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Xinong979 | Large-spike | Xinong979 | Large-spike | Xinong979 | Large-spike | Xinong979 | Large-spike | Xinong979 | Large-spike | Xinong979 | Large-spike | Xinong979 | Large-spike | |
NlWw | 17.26±0.22cd | 16.14±0.38d | 7.72±0.19e | 6.64±0.21e | 0.437±0.01d | 0.521±0.01d | 258.0±1.08e | 250.8±1.05g | 2.25±0.07a | 2.44±0.06bc | 39.49±0.69a | 30.98±0.66a | 0.330±0.01a | 0.351±0.01a |
NlWm | 13.67±0.36b | 11.44±0.38b | 4.35±0.21c | 6.89±0.14e | 0.229±0.01b | 0.381±0.01c | 236.1±1.75b | 230.2±0.87c | 3.21±0.20b | 1.67±0.08a | 60.55±3.37c | 30.15±1.26a | 0.389±0.01d | 0.402±0.01d |
NlWs | 6.96±0.39a | 6.86±0.41a | 1.16±0.07a | 2.97±0.13ab | 0.125±0.00a | 0.162±0.01a | 230.3±1.12b | 219.0±1.06a | 6.17±0.49d | 2.33±0.17b | 56.37±4.59c | 43.46±3.81bc | 0.400±0.01e | 0.436±0.01f |
NmWw | 18.23±0.18d | 17.65±0.49d | 8.15±0.24e | 7.85±0.16f | 0.558±0.01e | 0.578±0.01e | 243.1±1.28c | 241.8±0.81ef | 2.25±0.07a | 2.26±0.07b | 32.77±0.85a | 30.67±1.26a | 0.365±0.01c | 0.375±0.01bc |
NmWm | 17.30±0.20cd | 14.14±0.59c | 7.24±0.31e | 4.16±0.20d | 0.400±0.01d | 0.261±0.01b | 234.0±1.17b | 219.4±1.91a | 2.43±0.12ab | 3.46±0.20de | 43.84±2.06aab | 54.45±2.71de | 0.388±0.01d | 0.429±0.01ef |
NmWs | 13.76±0.25b | 11.55±0.46b | 3.41±0.17b | 3.44±0.168c | 0.147±0.01a | 0.185±0.01a | 212.7±2.19a | 225.4±1.44bc | 4.10±0.17c | 3.41±0.21de | 95.68±4.77d | 63.08±3.16e | 0.448±0.01f | 0.417±0.01e |
NhWw | 18.22±0.18d | 17.82±0.39d | 7.89±0.23e | 6.88±0.24e | 0.537±0.01e | 0.493±0.01d | 236.3±1.20b | 237.6±1.11d | 2.33±0.07ab | 2.61±0.07bc | 34.09±1.05a | 36.20±0.86ab | 0.386±0.01d | 0.386±0.01c |
NhWm | 16.76±0.27c | 12.03±0.48b | 5.57±0.25d | 4.04±0.10cd | 0.311±0.01c | 0.249±0.01b | 250.1±0.75d | 243.3±1.01f | 3.06±0.15ab | 2.98±0.12cd | 54.36±1.91bc | 48.67±2.32cd | 0.346±0.01b | 0.368±0.01b |
NhWs | 14.21±0.23b | 10.40±0.45b | 5.52±0.24d | 2.69±0.14a | 0.281±0.01c | 0.171±0.01a | 243.7±1.82cd | 224.3±1.00ab | 2.62±0.14ab | 3.91±0.13e | 51.37±2.86bc | 61.87±4.32e | 0.360±0.01c | 0.417±0.01e |
C | *** | *** | ns | *** | *** | *** | *** | |||||||
N | *** | *** | *** | *** | ns | *** | *** | |||||||
W | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | |||||||
C×N | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | |||||||
C×W | *** | ns | ** | ** | *** | * | *** | |||||||
N×W | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | |||||||
C×W×N | ** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** | *** |
Pn—net photosynthetic rate; E–transpiration rate, Gs—stomatal conductance; Ci—intercellular CO2 concentration; WUE—instantaneous water use efficiency; WUEi—intrinsic water use efficiency; Ls—stomatal limitation value (based on [9]); C—cultivars; N—nitrogen; W—water. Nl—low N; Nm—medium N; Nh—high N; Ww—well-watered; Wm—moderate water stress; Ws—severe water stress. Values are means± standard error (SE), n = 3. Different letters within the same column denote the differences between the treatments (P<0.05). NS: no significant at the 0.05 level; *, **, ***, significant at P<0.05, P<0.01 and P<0.001, respectively.