Table 2.
Themes | Facilitators | Barriers |
---|---|---|
1. Impact on clinical decision-making | - Faster decision-making - Earlier triaging of possible serious illness - Improved confidence in treatment decisions (e.g. antibiotics) |
- Immediate results not helpful in some situations (e.g., monitoring of chronic conditions) - Over-reliance undermining physician clinical skills - Increase in unnecessary testing |
2. Accuracy concerns | - Improved ‘rule out’ value when used with clinical features | - Less accurate than laboratory tests - Positive test results often misleading |
3. Impact of POCT on staff and clinic workflow | - Reduced clinic difficulties with patient follow-up for laboratory tests between office visits - More POCT may alleviate pressure on under-staffed laboratories |
- Concerns increased testing volume may extend patient visits/overwhelm providers - Insufficient healthcare personnel within clinics to manage additional testing - Risk of error in reporting results for tests without EMR interface |
4. Impact on perceived patient experience and patient-physician relationship | - Improved patient-provider communication - Patient awareness of work involved in making a diagnosis, making providers feel more valued - Improved patient understanding and acceptance of provider treatment decisions (e.g., antibiotics) - Perceived greater acceptability of fingerstick blood testing by patients and clinic |
|
5. Influence of cost, regulation and quality control | - Perceived expense compared to laboratory tests - Uncertainty about reimbursement rates from insurers and loss of clinic revenue - Lack of laboratory trust in giving clinics responsibility for quality control processes - Lack of clinic autonomy to adopt new tests |