Table 1.
Study | Study design | Type of needle | Patients included, core vs. standard | Target organ | Mean no. of pass for D or A | Procurement, histologic/optimal core, n (%) |
On-site pathologist | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Core needle | Standard needle | |||||||
Bang et al. (2012) [19] | Prospective randomized | 22 G core vs. standard | 28/28 | Pancreas | 1.28/1.61 (D) | 23/28 (82) | 28/28 (100) | Yes |
22/28 (80) | 19/28 (67) | |||||||
Witt et al. (2013) [25] | Retrospective cohort | 22 G core vs. standard | 18/18 | Pancreas | 2.11/2.94 (A) | NA | NA | No |
Lymph nodes | ||||||||
Stomach | ||||||||
Hucl et al. (2013) [20] | Prospective crossover | 22 G core & standard | 145/145 | Pancreas | 1.23/2-47 (A) | 125/145 (86) | 127/145 (88) | No |
Lymph nodes | 100/145 (69) | 96/145 (66) | ||||||
Strand et al. (2014) [21] | Prospective crossover | 22 G core & standard | 32/32 | Pancreas | 1.4/2.9a | 27/32 (84) | NA | Yes |
19/27 (70) | ||||||||
Lee et al. (2014) [22] | Prospective randomized | 22/25 G core vs. standard | 58/58 | Pancreas | 1.0/2.0 (D)b | NA | NA | Yes |
Vanbiervliet Prospective et al. (2014) crossover [23] | Prospective crossover | 22 G core & standard | 40/40 | Pancreas | NA | 56/80 (70) | 70/80 (88) | No |
53/80 (66) | 66/80 (83) | |||||||
Berzosa et al. (2015) [26] | Retrospective cohort | 22 G core & 25 G standard | 61/61 | Pancreas | 1.7/3.5 | NA | NA | Yes (1/2 centers) |
Iwashita et al. (2013) [27] | Retrospective single arm | 25 G core | 50 | Pancreas | 4b | NA | No | |
16/50 (32) | ||||||||
Larghi et al. (2013) [7] | Prospective single arm | 22 G core | 61 | Pancreas | NA | 55/60 (92) | - | No |
54/60 (89) | ||||||||
Fabbri et al. (2015) [28] | Retrospective single arm | 22 G core | 68 | Pancreas | 1.5a | 58/68 (85) | - | No |
36/68 (53) | ||||||||
Paik et al. (2015) [24] | Prospective single arm | 22 G core | 133 | Pancreas | NA | NA | No | |
Lymph nodes | - | |||||||
Others |
D, diagnosis; A, adequacy; G, gauge; NA, not available.
Mean number of passes per lesion irrespective of diagnosis and adequacy.
Median number of passes.