Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 11;7:1630. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2016.01630

Table 1.

Mean economic optimum N rate (EONR, kg N ha-1) across 16-years for: observed, Obs; un-calibrated Agricultural Production Systems sIMulator (APSIM) model, Unc; calibrated model, Cal; and the return to N approach from the calibrated model, RTN.

Obs Unc Cal RTN Obs-Unc Obs-Cal Obs-RTN


Rotation Mean values Differences
Average of years ± SD1 CC 188 ± 42 190 ± 82 225 ± 33 176 ± 21 -2 -37 12
SC 149 ± 48 99 ± 71 137 ± 43 118 ± 30 50 12 31
Pooled2 CC 187 226 228 195 -39 -41 -8
SC 158 140 147 140 18 10 18

Absolute differences between EONR-Obs and simulations are also shown. Continuous corn, CC and soybean-corn rotation, SC.

1 Individual annual optimum N rate estimates were averaged across 16-years and the standard deviation (SD) calculated.

2 Individual annual corn yield values were first averaged across years and then the optimum N rates estimated.