TABLE 1.
Subitems | Low risk of bias (two-thirds or more of included studies) = 0.5 points for each subitem | High risk of bias (over one-third of included studies) = 0 points for each subitem | Unclear risk of bias = 0.25 points for each subitem |
Ascertainment of exposure | E.g., validated, calibrated FFQ or 24-h recall, diet history, or diet records (multiple days); | E.g., unvalidated FFQ, single 24-h recall, diet records, or diet history; | Assessed, but unclear2 |
Diet-associated biomarkers, e.g., 24-h urine | Diet associated biomarkers: morning urine; | ||
Or not assessed | |||
Adjusted basic model and outcome-relevant adjustments | Basic model: ≥2 factors—sex, age, education, ethnicity; if only one sex included, then ≥1 factor; | Basic model: <2 factors—sex, age, education, ethnicity; if only one sex included, then ≤1 factor; | Assessed, but unclear2 |
Outcome relevant adjustments: ≥3 factors—alcohol, energy intake, smoking, physical activity, BMI, CVD risk factors (blood pressure, dyslipidemia, family history of CVD) | Outcome-relevant adjustments: <3 factors—alcohol, energy intake, smoking, physical activity, BMI, CVD risk factors (blood pressure, dyslipidemia, family history of CVD); | ||
Or not assessed | |||
Assessment of outcome | E.g., record linkage (ICD codes), accepted clinical criteria, independent or blind assessment | E.g., self-report (not validated); | Assessed, but unclear2 |
Or not assessed | |||
Adequacy of follow-up duration | E.g., median ≥10 y for CVD, median ≥5 y for T2DM | E.g., median <10 y for CVD, median <5 y for T2DM; | Assessed, but unclear2 |
Or not assessed |
CVD, cardiovascular disease; ICD, International Classification of Diseases; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus.
E.g., when too few details are available to make a judgment for low or high risk of bias.