Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: Curr Osteoporos Rep. 2016 Dec;14(6):292–309. doi: 10.1007/s11914-016-0340-1

Table.

Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms Studied in Conjunction with EARR.

Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms Studied in Conjunction with EARR
Chr Gene Marker Type of Marker Population tested Results Refs
2q14 .1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
35 White American families from Indiana, USA

Families having at least 2 siblings who had received
full-banded comprehensive orthodontic treatment;
2.82 years (±1.09 stdev) average length of treatment
No statistical association [16]
2q14.1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
45 sporadic EARR patients including two sibling
pairs with EARR


44 controls

All subjects from Aachen, Germany
The rs1800587 2/2 [T/T]
genotype was associated with
EARR compared to the control
group

(p < 0.032)
[68]
2q14 .1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
54 Caucasian orthodontic patients from Seville,
Spain


25 individuals with EARR > 2 mm

29 Controls
No statistical association

p= 0.09
[29]
2q14.1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
73 root filled teeth (35 with EARR > 2mm and 38
non-EARR teeth)


73 vital control teeth (30 with EARR > 2 mm and 43
non-EARR teeth)


All patients were from Seville, Spain and had
undergone root canal treatment in a maxillary premolar
but not in the contra-lateral tooth and had received
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique) at least 1 year later.
No statistical association of
EARR with non-vital
endodontically-treated teeth
[69]
2q14.1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
93 orthodontic patients from Seville, Spain


39 individuals with >2 mm of EARR on root-filled teeth
after orthodontic treatment


54 Controls
No statistical association of
EARR with non-vital
endodontically-treated teeth
[70]
2q14 .1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
32 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors (age
15.0 ± 4.1 years)


74 controls (age 15.2 ± 5.3 years)


All individuals were white from Brno, Czech Republic;
treated with fixed appliances
No statistical association [30]
2q14 .1 Interleukin-1α

(IL-1α; OMIM
#147760)
rs1800587

(−889 C/T)
Promoter
variation
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of maxillary incisors; 38
females and 29 males


67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953;

C/T rev)


*Allele 2 (T)
associated
with more

IL-1

production
(See a, b, c)
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
35 White American families in Indiana, USA



Families having at least 2 siblings who had received
full-banded comprehensive orthodontic treatment



2.82 years (±1.09 stdev) average length of treatment
rs1143634 was linked to the
EARR phenotype

(p= 0.0003)


Allele-1/Allele-1 (C/C)
homozygous individuals showed
a 5.6 fold increase risk of EARR
> 2mm (95% CI 1.9–21.2)
compared to C/T and T/T
individuals
[16]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
61 orthodontic patients from San Paulo, Brazil



23 affected individuals

38 control individuals

EARR in the central and lateral maxillary incisors in
the post-treatment period
Allele 1 (C) predisposed the
subjects to EARR

(OR = 4.0)
[34]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
45 sporadic EARR patients including two sibling
pairs with EARR


49 controls



All subjects from Aachen, Germany
No statistical association


Allele-1 (C) occurred slightly less
often in the EARR affected
individuals compared to controls
[68]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
54 Caucasian orthodontic patients from Seville,
Spain



25 individuals with EARR > 2 mm

29 Controls
Allele-1/Allele-1 (CC)
homozygous individuals had an
increased risk of post-
orthodontic EARR (OR 3.48;
p=0.027; 95%CI=1.12–10.72)
[29]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
73 root filled teeth (35 with EARR > 2mm and 38
non-EARR teeth)



73 vital control teeth (30 with EARR > 2 mm and 43
non-EARR teeth)


All patients were from Seville, Spain and had
undergone root canal treatment in a maxillary premolar
but not in the contra-lateral tooth and had received
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique) at least 1 year later.
Homozygous subjects 2/2 [TT]
had 2X the risk of post-
orthodontic EARR in non-vital,
endodontically-treated teeth
[OR, 2.032 (p= 0.031);
95%CI=1.99–14.77] when
compared to control teeth with
vital pulp.

There was an increased
predisposition of EARR for
control teeth with vital pulp
and control root-filled teeth
when the subject is
homozygous for Allele-1 (C)
[OR, 5.05 (p= 0.002)] and [OR,
2.77 (p= 0.037)], respectively.
[69]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
93 orthodontic patients from Seville, Spain



39 individuals with >2 mm of EARR on root-filled teeth
after orthodontic treatment



54 Controls
Homozygous subjects
(2/2[TT]) and (1/1[CC]), had an
increased risk of post-
orthodontic EARR in non-vital,
endondontically-treated teeth
(odds ratio = 11.59; p=0.006;
95%CI= 1.36–98.64) and (odds
ratio = 2.54; p=0.035;
95%CI=1.05–6.12), respectively
[70]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
32 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors (age
15.0 ± 4.1 years)



74 controls (age 15.2 ± 5.3 years)



All individuals were white from Brno, Czech Republic;
treated with fixed appliances
No statistical association [30]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
195 total patients from Coimbra, Portugal

(72 males and 123 female patients)

17.24 + 6.8 years old (average age + stdev); Average
treatment time was 36 ± 10 months



Portuguese Caucasian origin with completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique); Six teeth were assessed: the four maxillary
incisors and the two maxillary canines
No statistical association [36]

[51]
2q14 .1 Interleukin -1β

(IL-1β; OMIM
#147720)
rs1143634

(+3954/

+3953 C/T)

*See note
above
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 5



TTC→TTT

Phe105Phe
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of maxillary incisors; 38
females and 29 males



67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
2q14.1–2 Interleukin-1
Receptor
Antagonist

(IL-1RN; OMIM
#147679)

Aliases:

IL-1ra, IL-1RA
rs315952

(+390 T/C)
Synonymous
variant in

Exon 4



AGT→AGC

Ser130Ser
195 total patients from Coimbra, Portugal

(72 males and 123 female patients)

17.24 + 6.8 years old (average age + stdev); Average
treatment time was 36 ± 10 months



Portuguese Caucasian origin with completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique); Six teeth were assessed: the four maxillary
incisors and the two maxillary canines
No statistical association [51]
2q14.1–2 Interleukin-1
Receptor
Antagonist

(IL-1RN; OMIM
#147679)

Aliases:

IL-1ra, IL-1RA
rs419598

(C/T fwd)
Synonymous
variant



GCT→GCC

Ala→Ala
54 Caucasian orthodontic patients from Seville,
Spain



25 individuals with EARR > 2 mm

29 Controls
Homozygous [1/1(TT)]

more likely to be affected with
EARR

(OR: 6.75; p= 0.001;
95%CI=2.04–22.27).
[29]
2q14.1–2 Interleukin-1
Receptor
Antagonist

(IL-1RN; OMIM
#147679)

Aliases:

IL-1ra, IL-1RA
rs419598

(C/T fwd)
Synonymous
variant



GCT→GCC

Ala→Ala
93 orthodontic patients from Seville, Spain



39 individuals with >2mm EARR following orthodontic
treatment on root-filled teeth



54 individuals with no EARR or EARR ≤ 2mm
following orthodontic treatment on root-filled teeth
Subjects homozygous
[1/1(TT)] for rs419598 were at
increased risk of EARR in
root-filled teeth (OR:10.85;
p=0.001;CI:95%=3.97 – 29.6)
[71]
2q14.1–2 Interleukin-1
Receptor
Antagonist

(IL-1RN; OMIM
#147679)

Aliases:

IL-1ra, IL-1RA
rs419598

(C/T fwd)
Synonymous
variant



GCT→GCC

Ala→Ala
Case-Control Study; 67 biologically unrelated
Caucasians with moderate to severe EARR of
maxillary incisors; 38 females and 29 males



67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls



All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
2q14.1–2 Interleukin-1
Receptor
Antagonist

(IL-1RN; OMIM
#147679)

Aliases:

IL-1ra, IL-1RA
86-bp
Variable
Number
Tandem
Repeat
(VNTR) in
2nd intron
Short allele

2 repeats
(240bp)


Long alleles

3 (326 bp),

4 (412bp),

5 (498bp), and

6 (584bp)
repeats
32 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors (age
15.0 ± 4.1 years)


74 controls (age 15.2 ± 5.3 years)





All individuals were white from Brno, Czech Republic;
treated with fixed appliances
IL1RN*12, *22 genotypes
and the short (*2) allele
were significantly
associated with EARR in
the subgroup of girls

(p= 0.04 and p= 0.02,

p= 0.02, respectively)
[30]
2q14.1–2 Interleukin-1
Receptor
Antagonist

(IL-1RN; OMIM
#147679)

Aliases:

IL-1ra, IL-1RA
rs419598

(C/T fwd)
Synonymous
variant


GCT→GCC

Ala→Ala
174 orthodontic patients within a Chinese Han
population


Left maxillary central incisors monitored for EARR in
3D during straight wire orthodontic treatment; Age
range 12–34 years; average 20.55 ± 6.54 months in
treatment
No statistical association [46]
Xq28 Interleukin-1
receptor-
activated
protein kinase

(IRAK1; OMIM
#300283)
rs1059703

(+6434;

C/T rev)
Non-
synonymous

Variant in Exon
12


TCG→TTG

Ser532Leu
195 total patients from Coimbra, Portugal

(72 males and 123 female patients)

17.24 + 6.8 years old (average age + stdev); Average
treatment time was 36 ± 10 months


Portuguese Caucasian origin with completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique); Six teeth were assessed: the four maxillary
incisors and the two maxillary canines
Homozygosity and
hemizygosity for the C-allele
was protective for EARR (p =
0.018)
[51]
7p15.3 Interleukin-6

(IL-6; OMIM
#147620)
rs1800796

(−634 C/G)
Promoter
variation
174 orthodontic patients within a Chinese Han
population


Left maxillary central incisors monitored for EARR in
3D during straight wire orthodontic treatment; Age
range 12–34 years; average 20.55 ± 6.54 months in
treatment
GC individuals had an
increased risk of EARR
[46]
6p12.2 Interleukin-17A
(IL-17A; OMIM #
603149)
rs2275913

(−197 G/A)
Promoter
variation
Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)


30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys: 19 girls)


69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No statistical association [72]
11q22.3 Caspase-1
(CASP1; OMIM
#147678);

Alias

Interleukin-1
Beta Converting
Enzyme (ICE)
rs530537

(A/G rev)
Intronic variant Case-Control Study; 67 biologically unrelated
Caucasians with moderate to severe EARR of
maxillary incisors; 38 females and 29 males



67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
11q22.3 Caspase-1
(CASP1; OMIM
#147678);

Alias

Interleukin-1
Beta Converting
Enzyme (ICE)
rs580253

(C/T rev)
Synonymous
variant


CTA→TTA

Leu→Leu
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of maxillary incisors; 38
females and 29 males


67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
11q22.3 Caspase-1
(CASP1; OMIM
#147678);

Alias

Interleukin-1
Beta Converting
Enzyme (ICE)
rs554344

(C/G fwd)
Near 3’ end of
the gene
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of maxillary incisors; 38
females and 29 males

67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
12q24.31 Purinergic-
receptor-P2X,
ligand-gated
ion channel 7
(P2RX7; OMIM
#602566)
rs208294

(+489 C/T)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant


CAT→TAT

His155Tyr

Gain-of-function
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of the maxillary incisors;
38 females and 29 males



67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls



All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
Individuals with CC&CT were
at higher risk for EARR than
individuals with TT (p=0.002)
[35]
12q24.31 Purinergic-
receptor-P2X,
ligand-gated
ion channel 7
(P2RX7; OMIM
#602566)
rs208294

(+489 C/T)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant


CAT→TAT

His155Tyr

Gain-of-function
Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)


30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys: 19 girls)



69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No association with individual
SNP



Association seen with
rs208294 + rs1718119
haplotype and EARR
[72]
12q24.31 Purinergic-
receptor-P2X,
ligand-gated
ion channel 7
(P2RX7; OMIM
#602566)
rs1718119

(+1068 G/A
fwd)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant in Exon
11


GCT→ACT

Ala348Thr

Gain-of-function
195 total patients from Coimbra, Portugal

(72 males and 123 female patients)

17.24 + 6.8 years old (average age + stdev); Average
treatment time was 36 ± 10 months


Portuguese Caucasian origin with completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique); Six teeth were assessed: the four maxillary
incisors and the two maxillary canines
The GG genotype for
rs1718119 was significantly
associated with EARR (p<0.01)
[36]
12q24.31 Purinergic-
receptor-P2X,
ligand-gated
ion channel 7
(P2RX7; OMIM
#602566)
rs1718119

(+1068 G/A
fwd)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant in Exon
11


GCT→ACT

Ala348Thr

Gain-of-function
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of the maxillary incisors;
38 females and 29 males



67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
12q24.31 Purinergic-
receptor-P2X,
ligand-gated
ion channel 7
(P2RX7; OMIM
#602566)
rs1718119

(+1068 G/A
fwd)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant in Exon
11


GCT→ACT

Ala348Thr

Gain-of-function
Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)


30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys: 19 girls)

69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No association with individual
SNP



Association seen with
rs208294 + rs1718119
haplotype and EARR
[72]
12q24.31 Purinergic-
receptor-P2X,
ligand-gated
ion channel 7
(P2RX7; OMIM
#602566)
rs2230912

(A/G)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant in

Exon 13


CAG→CGG

Gln460Arg
67 biologically unrelated Caucasians with
moderate to severe EARR of the maxillary
incisors; 38 females and 29 males




67 age and sex-matched biologically unrelated
Caucasian controls


All subjects from Northern Indiana, USA received
standard orthodontic treatment
No statistical association [35]
18q21.33 Tumor Necrosis
Factor
Receptor
Superfamily
Member 11a
(TNFRSF11A;
OMIM #603499)
Alias: Receptor

Activator of

NF-KB (RANK)
D18S64



D18S64 is
tightly linked
to
TNFRSF11A
Microsatellite 38 American Caucasian families

with a total of 79 siblings who completed

comprehensive orthodontic treatment.


Evaluated EARR in the maxillary central incisors, the
mandibular central incisors, and the mesial and distal
roots of the mandibular

first molars
Linkage of maxillary central
incisor EARR to microsatellite
marker D18S64


(LOD = 2.5; p = 0.02)
[73]
18q21.33 Tumor Necrosis
Factor
Receptor
Superfamily
Member 11a
(TNFRSF11A;
OMIM #603499)
Alias: Receptor

Activator of

NF-KB (RANK)
rs1805034

(C/T fwd)
Non-
synonymous
variant in Exon
6


GCG→GTG

Val192Ala
195 total patients from Coimbra, Portugal

(72 males and 123 female patients)

17.24 + 6.8 years old (average age + stdev); Average
treatment time was 36 ± 10 months


Portuguese Caucasian origin with completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique); Six teeth were assessed: the four maxillary
incisors and the two maxillary canines
No statistical association [36]
8q24.12 Tumor Necrosis
Factor
Receptor
Superfamily
Member 11b
(TNFRSF11B;
OMIM #602643)
Alias: (OPG)
Osteoprotegerin
rs2073618

(+1181 C/G)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant

AAC→AAG

Asn3Lys
135 Caucasian subjects were studied from Indiana,
USA; EARR >2 mm in at least one maxillary central
incisor


Mean age of the patients pre-treatment was 14.6 ±6.9
years (stdev); average treatment time was 1.6 ± 0.5
years (stdev)
G allele was associated with
EARR

(p= 0.003)
[6]
8q24.12 Tumor Necrosis
Factor
Receptor
Superfamily
Member 11b
(TNFRSF11B;
OMIM #602643)
Alias: (OPG)
Osteoprotegerin
rs3102735

(−163 A/G
rev strand)
Promoter
variation
195 total patients from Coimbra, Portugal

(72 males and 123 female patients)

17.24 + 6.8 years old (average age + stdev); Average
treatment time was 36 ± 10 months


Portuguese Caucasian origin with completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment (straight-wire
technique); Six teeth were assessed: the four maxillary
incisors and the two maxillary canines
No statistical association [36]
8q24.12 Tumor Necrosis
Factor
Receptor
Superfamily
Member 11b
(TNFRSF11B;
OMIM #602643)
Alias: (OPG)
Osteoprotegerin
rs3102735

(−163 C/T
fwd strand)
Promoter
variation
Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)

30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys: 19 girls)


69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No statistical association [72]
8q24.12 Tumor Necrosis
Factor
Receptor
Superfamily
Member 11b
(TNFRSF11B;
OMIM #602643)
Alias: (OPG)
Osteoprotegerin
rs2073618

(+1181 C/G)
Non-

Synonymous

Variant


AAC→AAG

Asn3Lys
Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)


30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys : 19 girls)


69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No statistical association [72]
6p21.33 Tumor Necrosis
Factor alpha
(TNFα; OMIM
#191160)
rs1800629

(−308 G/A)
Promoter
variation
38 American Caucasian families

with a total of 79 siblings who completed
comprehensive orthodontic treatment.



Evaluated EARR in the maxillary central incisors, the
mandibular central incisors, and the mesial and distal
roots of the mandibular first molars
No linkage identified [73]
1p36.12 Tissue-
NonSpecific
ALkaline
Phosphatase

(TNSALP; OMIM
#171760)

Alias: Alkaline
phosphatase,
tissue-
nonspecific
isozyme (ALPL)
AL215L 38 American Caucasian families

with a total of 79 siblings who completed

comprehensive orthodontic treatment


Evaluated EARR in the maxillary central incisors, the
mandibular central incisors, and the mesial and distal
roots of the mandibular

first molars
No linkage identified [73]
4q22.1 Osteopontin
(OPN) Aliases:
bone sialoprotein
I (BSP-1/BNSP),
secreted
phosphoprotein
1 (SPP1, OMIM


#166490)
rs11730582

(−443T/C)
5'near gene 87 Caucasian orthodontic patients from Seville,
Spain


37 with EARR (>2 mm)

50 Controls

Mean length of orthodontic treatment 27.5 ± 8.3
months (stdev); EARR measured at the completion of
orthodontic treatment
Allele-2/Allele-2 [CC]
increased risk of EARR
(OR:11.68; p<0.039;

95%CI = 1.12–121.06) compared
with other genotypes;

Allele-1 [A] is protective for
EARR (OR: 0.20; p=0.025;
95%CI= 0.05–0.81)
[74]
4q22.1 Osteopontin
(OPN) Aliases:
bone sialoprotein
I (BSP-1/BNSP),
secreted
phosphoprotein
1 (SPP1, OMIM
#166490)
rs11730582

(–443T/C)
5′near gene Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)


30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys : 19 girls)


69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No statistical association [72]
4q22.1 Osteopontin
(OPN) Aliases:
bone sialoprotein
I (BSP-1/BNSP),
secreted
phosphoprotein
1 (SPP1, OMIM
#166490)
rs9138

(+1239A/C)
3′ UTR 87 Caucasian orthodontic patients from Seville,
Spain


37 with EARR (>2 mm)

50 Controls


Mean length of orthodontic treatment 27.5 ± 8.3
months (stdev); EARR measured at the completion of
orthodontic treatment
Allele-2/Allele-2 [CC] at
increased risk of post-
orthodontic EARR

(OR: 4.10; p= 0.045;

95%CI = 1.03–16.35)


Allele-1 [T] is protective for
EARR (OR: 0.035; p=0.035’
95%CI= 0.062–0.90)
[74]
4q22.1 Osteopontin
(OPN)

also known as
bone sialoprotein
I (BSP-1 or
BNSP), secreted
phosphoprotein
1 (SPP1, OMIM
#166490)
rs9138

(+1239 A/C)
3′ UTR Case-control retrospective study

99 Caucasian children of Czech origin

15.0 ± 4.7 (mean age ± standard deviation)


30 individuals with EARR of maxillary incisors(11
boys : 19 girls)


69 unrelated controls (26 boys: 43 girls)
No statistical association [72]
12q13.11 Vitamin D
Receptor

(VDR; OMIM
#601769)
rs731236

(C/T; also
termed
TaqI)
Synonymous
variant in Exon 1



AAT→ ATC
Ile→Ile
377 Brazilian Orthodontic

Patients Diagnosed with Class II Div 1

160 individuals with EARR ≤ 1.43

179 individuals with EARR > 1.43
38 untreated individuals


Mean age, 14.9 years (range, 8–21 years); EARR
measured after the first 6 months of treatment
CC+CT versus TT

C allele was protective for
EARR (p= 0.091; OR=0.29;
95%CI = 0.07–1.23)
[39]
a, b, c

References related to rs1143634 influencing IL-1B production: (a) Pociot F, Molvig J, Wogensen LW, Orsaae H, Nerup J. A Taq I polymorphism in the human interleukin-1 (IL-1) gene correlates with IL-1 secretion in vitro. Eur J Clin Invest 1992; 22:396–402. (b) Iwasaki LR, Gibson CS, Crouch LD, Marx DB, Pandey JP, Nickel JC. Speed of tooth movement is related to stress and IL-1 gene polymorphisms. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2006; 130. 698.e1–9, and (c) Latkovski G, Licis N, Kalnins U. C-reactive protein levels and common polymorphism of the interleukin-1 gene cluster and interleukin-6 gene in patients with coronary heart disease. Eur J Immunogenet 2004; 31:207–13.

Abbreviations: OR=odds ratio; CI=confidence interval