Study | Subsamples | Age group | Gender | N | Execution d [95% CI] | Observation d [95% CI] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Andelin (2011) | >18 years | Mixed | 30 | 0.53 [0.27, 0.79] | 0.21 [–0.03, 0.44] | |
Avanzini et al. (2012) | >18 years | Mixed | 11 | 0.68 [0.21, 1.15] | ||
Babiloni et al. (2008) | >18 years | Mixed | 12 | 0.52 [0.22, 0.81] | ||
Behmer & Jantzen (2011) | Musicians | >18 years | Mixed | 12 | 0.69 [0.24, 1.14] | |
Nonmusicians | >18 years | Mixed | 12 | 0.69 [0.24, 1.14] | ||
Bernier et al. (2007) | Nonclinical | >18 years | >70% male | 15 | 0.95 [0.48, 1.41] | 1.01 [0.53, 1.50] |
Bernier et al. (2013) | 5–18 years | >70% male | 14 | 0.37 [0.01, 0.72] | ||
Bilyk (2012) | 18–28 years | >70% female | 37 | 0.19 [–0.03, 0.40] | ||
Braadbaart et al. (2013) | >18 years | >70% male | 15 | 0.19 [–0.18, 0.56] | ||
Brown et al. (2013) | >18 years | >70% female | 17 | 0.33 [0.01, 0.65] | ||
Cannon et al. (2014) | Novices | >18 years | >70% female | 12 | 0.27 [0.01, 0.54] | |
Observers | >18 years | >70% male | 10 | 0.62 [0.28, 0.96] | ||
Performers | >18 years | >70% female | 11 | 0.88 [0.35, 1.40] | ||
Cochin et al. (1998) | >18 years | Mixed | 40 | 0.26 [0.11, 0.40] | ||
Cochin et al. (1999) | >18 years | Mixed | 20 | 0.46 [0.15, 0.77] | 0.58 [0.25, 0.91] | |
Cochin et al. (2001) | 0–4 years | N/Rb | 30 | 0.21 [0.11, 0.32] | ||
Colombi (2008) | Nonclinical | 5–18 years | >70% male | 9 | 0.40 [–0.05, 0.86] | |
Experiment | 5–18 years | >70% male | 29 | 0.04 [–0.05, 0.14] | ||
2/nonclinical | ||||||
Experiment | 5–18 years | >70% male | 19 | 0.00 [–0.28, 0.28] | ||
3/nonclinical | ||||||
Cooper et al. (2013) | >18 years | Mixed | 20 | 0.11 [–0.17, 0.39] | ||
Cuellar et al. (2012) | Experiment 1 | >18 years | >70% female | 10 | 0.17 [0.04, 0.30] | |
Experiment 2 | >18 years | >70% female | 13 | 0.14 [0.04, 0.24] | ||
de Klerk et al. (2015)a | 0–4 years | Mixed | 31 | 0.00 [–0.22, 0.22] | ||
Derambure et al. (1997) | Nonclinical | >18 years | N/Rb | 10 | 0.65 [0.17, 1.14] | |
Désy & Lepage (2013) | >18 years | Mixed | 18 | 0.65 [0.29, 1.01] | 0.66 [0.30, 1.02] | |
Fargier et al. (2012) | >18 years | Mixed | 16 | 0.11 [–0.20, 0.42] | ||
Francuz & Zapała (2011) | >18 years | Mixed | 10 | 0.96 [0.38, 1.53] | ||
Frenkel-Toledo et al. (2013) | >18 years | Mixed | 27 | 1.16 [0.23, 2.08] | 1.25 [0.31, 2.19] | |
Giromini et al. (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 19 | 0.51 [0.18, 0.84] | ||
Gutsell & Inzlicht (2010) | Mixed | 30 | 0.51 [0.25, 0.77] | 0.14 [−0.09, 0.37] | ||
Heimann et al. (2013) | >18 years | Mixed | 15 | 0.68 [0.28, 1.08] | 0.68 [0.28, 1.08] | |
Holmes et al. (2006) | >18 years | >70% female | 6 | 0.00 [–0.51, 0.51] | 0.00 [–0.51, 0.51] | |
Kranczioch et al. (2008) | >18 years | >70% female | 13 | 0.71 [0.23, 1.19] | ||
Kumar et al. (2013) | N/Rb | >70% female | 17 | 0.36 [0.14, 0.59] | ||
Leocani et al. (1997) | N/Rb | Mixed | 9 | 0.39 [–0.06, 0.84] | ||
Lepage & Théoret (2006) | 5–18 years | Mixed | 15 | 0.17 [–0.18, 0.52] | ||
Li et al. (2011) | >18 years | Mixed | 14 | 0.51 [0.13, 0.89] | ||
Marshall et al. (2009) | N/Rb | Mixed | 20 | 0.39 [0.09, 0.69] | ||
Marshall et al. (2011) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 30 | 0.31 [0.07, 0.55] | 0.31 [0.07, 0.56] | |
Martineau & Cochin (2003) | Nonclinical | 0–4 years | Mixed | 14 | 0.07 [–0.14, 0.29] | |
Martineau et al. (2008) | 5–18 years | Mixed | 14 | 0.02 [–0.31, 0.35] | ||
McCormick et al. (2012) | >18 years | >70% male | 16 | 0.33 [0.20, 0.47] | ||
McGarry et al. (2012) | >18 years | >70% female | 33 | 0.22 [0.00, 0.45] | 0.22 [0.00, 0.45] | |
Meyer et al. (2011) | 0–4 years | >70% male | 7 | 0.83 [0.19, 1.48] | ||
Milston et al. (2013) | >18 years | >70% female | 26 | 0.46 [0.19, 0.74] | 0.46 [0.19, 0.74] | |
Moore et al. (2008) | >18 years | Mixed | 34 | 0.29 [0.07, 0.51] | ||
Moore et al. (2012) | N/Rb | Mixed | 11 | 0.37 [0.19, 0.55] | ||
Müller-Putz et al. (2007) | Nonclinical | >18 years | >70% male | 9 | 0.49 [0.02, 0.96] | |
Muthukumaraswamy & Johnson (2004a) | >18 years | Mixed | 13 | 0.38 [0.01, 0.76] | ||
Muthukumaraswamy & Johnson (2004b) | >18 years | Mixed | 8 | 0.00 [–0.44, 0.44] | 0.00 [–0.44, 0.44] | |
Muthukumaraswamy et al. (2004) | >18 years | Mixed | 12 | 0.40 [0.01, 0.79] | 0.40 [0.01, 0.79] | |
Nyström (2008) | Adults | >18 years | N/Rb | 15 | 0.35 [0.01, 0.69] | |
Infants | 0–4 years | N/Rb | 19 | 0.31 [0.00, 0.61] | ||
Nyström et al. (2011) | 0–4 years | N/Rb | 23 | 0.27 [0.00, 0.54] | ||
Oberman et al. (2007) | Experiment 1 | >18 years | >70% female | 17 | 0.36 [0.04, 0.69] | |
Experiment 2 | >18 years | >70% female | 20 | 0.51 [0.19, 0.83] | ||
Oberman et al. (2008) | Nonclinical | 5–18 years | >70% male | 13 | 0.61 [0.19, 1.02] | |
Oberman et al. (2005) | Nonclinical | 5–18 years | >70% male | 10 | 0.72 [0.22, 1.23] | 0.40 [–0.03, 0.83] |
Orgs et al. (2008) | Dancers | >18 years | Mixed | 10 | 0.96 [0.38, 1.53] | |
Nondancers | >18 years | Mixed | 10 | 0.23 [–0.18, 0.64] | ||
Perry & Bentin (2009) | >18 years | Mixed | 24 | 0.23 [–0.04, 0.49] | ||
Perry & Bentin (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 24 | 0.13 [–0.13, 0.39] | ||
Perry et al. (2011) | >18 years | Mixed | 28 | 0.25 [0.00, 0.49] | 0.25 [0.00, 0.49] | |
Perry et al. (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 24 | 0.55 [0.26, 0.85] | ||
Pfurtscheller & Neuper (1992) | N/Rb | N/Rb | 3 | 1.57 [0.13, 3.02] | ||
Pineda & Oberman (2006) | >18 years | Mixed | 18 | 0.32 [0.01, 0.62] | 0.20 [–0.01, 0.41] | |
Pineda et al. (2011) | >18 years | Mixed | 24 | 0.56 [0.26, 0.86] | ||
Porcelli et al. (2013) | >18 years | >70% female | 24 | 0.37 [–0.53, 1.26] | ||
Puzzo et al. (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 20 | 0.38 [0.08, 0.68] | ||
Raymaekers et al. (2009) | Nonclinical | 5–18 years | >70% male | 20 | 0.54 [0.22, 0.87] | 0.41 [0.11, 0.72] |
Reid et al. (2011) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 10 | 0.67 [0.18, 1.16] | 0.11 [−0.29, 0.50] | |
Ruysschaert et al. (2013) | Live setting group | 0–4 years | Mixed | 18 | 0.30 [–0.01, 0.60] | |
Video setting group | 0–4 years | Mixed | 16 | 0.00 [–0.31, 0.31) | ||
Schuch et al. (2010) | >18 years | >70% female | 27 | 0.99 [0.63, 1.34] | 0.57 [0.28, 0.85] | |
Serrien & Brown (2003) | N/Rb | N/Rb | 6 | 0.66 [0.03, 1.29] | ||
Silas et al. (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 33 | 0.43 [0.19, 0.67] | 0.35 [0.12, 0.58] | |
Southgate & Begus (2013) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 33 | 0.20 [–0.19, 0.59] | ||
Southgate et al. (2010) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 22 | 0.29 [0.01, 0.56] | ||
Southgate et al. (2009) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 15 | 0.71 [0.30, 1.12] | 0.42 [0.07, 0.77] | |
Stancák & Pfurtscheller (1996a) | >18 years | Mixed | 10 | 0.45 [0.01, 0.89] | ||
Stancák et al. (1997) | >18 years | Mixed | 13 | 0.38 [0.01, 0.76] | ||
Stancák & Pfurtscheller (1996b) | >18 years | Mixed | 23 | 0.27 [0.00, 0.54] | ||
Streltsova et al. (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 11 | 1.18 [0.56, 1.81] | 0.41 [0.20, 0.61] | |
Ulloa & Pineda (2007) | >18 years | >70% female | 20 | 0.30 [0.00, 0.59] | ||
Upshaw et al. (2014)a | 0–4 years | N/Rb | 23 | 0.25 [–0.24, 0.74] | 0.06 [–0.12, 0.24] | |
van Elk et al. (2008) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 12 | 0.40 [0.01, 0.79] | ||
Virji-Babul et al. (2012)c | 0–4 years | Mixed | 10 | |||
Warreyn et al. (2012) | 0–4 years | Mixed | 17 | 0.48 [0.14, 0.82] | 0.40 [0.07, 0.73] | |
Woodruff et al. (2011) | N/Rb | Mixed | 39 | 0.28 [0.07, 0.48] | 0.28 [0.07, 0.48] | |
Wriesnegger et al. (2013) | >18 years | >70% female | 17 | 0.14 [0.02, 0.26] | ||
Yang et al. (2009) | >18 years | >70% male | 16 | 0.13 [–0.13, 0.39] | ||
Yuan et al. (2010) | >18 years | Mixed | 10 | 0.96 [0.38, 1.53] |
Note. CI - confidence interval.
Unpublished at the time of data request.
Specific age/gender distribution of participants was not reported (N/R); thus, we could not assign a code.
95% CI for observation was calculated for parietal (0.41[–0.02, 0.85]) and temporal (0.11[–0.28, 0.51]) areas.