Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 23;6:35728. doi: 10.1038/srep35728

Table 4. Quality assessment conducted according to the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for all the included studies.

First author and Ref. no. Quality indicators
Selection Comparability Exposure
Wu et al.11 *** * **
Chen et al.12 *** * ***
Chen et al.13 *** * ***
Garcia et al.14 ** * **
Heidi et al.15 *** * **
Araujo et al.16 *** * **
Singla et al.17 *** * ***
Thye et al.18 **** * ***
de Wit et al.19 *** * **
Capparelli et al.20 *** * **
Cossar et al.21 ** * **
Alagarasu et al.22 *** * *
Soborg et al.23 *** * *
Liu et al.24 *** * ***
Garcia et al.25 **** * **
Selvaraj et al.26 *** * *
Fitness et al.27 **** * **
Soborg et al.28 *** * **
Ozbaş et al.29 * * **
Selvaraj et al.30 *** * **
Hoal et al.31 **** * **
Bellamy et al.32 ** * **