Table 1.
Reference | Study design (duration) | Intervention | Sample size (disease duration) | Outcome measure | Results in the GC vs ctrl group |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Boers et al24 | RCT, MC, DB (80 wks) | • SSZ + MTX + prednisolone (tapered from 60 to 7.5 mg/d in 6 wks) • SSZ alone |
N=155 (<2 yrs) • GC arm: 76 • Ctrl arm: 79 |
• Disease activity and physical function • Radiographic damage |
• Rapid improvement, sustained up to wk 28, no longer significant after prednisone withdrawal; at wk 28, higher ACR20 (72% vs 49%, P=0.006) and ACR50 response rate (49% vs 27%, P=0.007) • Significantly slower progression at wk 28, persisting after prednisone withdrawal up to 5 yrs51 |
Svensson et al25 | RCT, MC, OL (2 yrs) | • DMARDs + prednisolone (7.5 mg/d) • DMARDs alone |
N=250 (≤1 yr) • GC arm: 119 • Ctrl arm: 131 |
• Radiographic damage • Disease activity and functional disability and impairment • Bone mineral density |
• Significantly less change already at 1 yr, lasting up to 2 yrs. Significantly less newly eroded joints at 1 yr and 2 yrs • Significant improvement already at month 3 by DAS28, HAQ, and SOFI, persisting throughout the study period; significantly higher remission rate at 2 yrs (55.5% vs 32.8%, P=0.0005); significantly lower CRP level at 3–6 months • Similar bone loss |
Wassenberg et al26 | RCT, MC, DB (2 yrs) | • DMARDs + prednisolone (5 mg/d) • DMARDs + placebo |
N=186 (<2 yrs) • GC arm: 80 • Ctrl arm: 86 |
• Radiographic damage • Clinical and functional outcomes, and remission rate |
• Significantly less progression by Ratingen score and SHS already at month 6 and up to month 24; lower % of eroded joints only at 6 months • Trend to higher overall improvement, but without between-group statistical significance |
Todoerti et al27 | RCT, SC, OL (2 yrs) | • Step-up DMARDs + prednisone (12.5 mg/d for 2 wks, tapered to 6.25 mg/d) • Step-up DMARDs |
N=210 (<1 yr) • GC arm: 105 • Ctrl arm: 105 |
• Clinical remission | • Significantly higher remission rate after 2 months (25.5% vs 8%, P=0.001); significantly higher probability of being in remission within 1 yr (OR: 1.965, 95% CI: 1.214–3.182, P=0.006) and up to 18 months (OR: 4.48, 95% CI: 1.35–14.82, P=0.014) |
Bakker et al28 | RCT, MC, DB (2 yrs) | • MTX-based tight control strategy + prednisone (10 mg/d) • MTX-based tight control strategy + placebo |
N=236 (<1 yr) • GC arm: 117 • Ctrl arm: 119 |
• Erosive joint damage • Disease activity |
• Limited and significantly lower at 2 yrs • More rapid improvement (already at month 3) of DAS28, ESR, VAS pain, and HAQ, yet not sustained over time; higher ACR50 response rate at 1 yr (56% vs 43%, P=0.037) and ACR70 at 2 yrs (38% vs 19%, P=0.002); shorter time to sustained remission (6 vs 11 months, P<0.001); reduced need for additional treatments (22% vs 50% of pts, P<0.001) and lower mean maximum MTX dose (19.7±6.1 vs 23.4±4.5 mg/wk, P<0.001) |
Montecucco et al29 | RCT, MC, OL (1 yr) | • Step-up MTX + prednisone (6.25 mg/d) • Step-up MTX |
N=220 (<1 yr) • GC arm: 110 • Ctrl arm: 110 |
• Disease activity • Subclinical synovitis |
• Significantly higher clinical remission rate at 1 yr (44.8% vs 27.8%, P=0.02); rapid (already at month 2) improvement of pain, DAS28, and number of swollen joints, although not sustained over time; rapid (from month 2) and persistent control of ESR and CRP serum levels • Significantly higher rate of PD negativity (69.8% vs 53.3% of pts, P=0.04) |
Abbreviations: ACR20, ≥20% improvement according to the American College of Rheumatology criteria; ACR50, ≥50% improvement according to the ACR criteria; ACR70, ≥70% improvement according to the ACR criteria; CI, confidence interval; CRP, C-reactive protein; ctrl, control; DAS28, disease activity score in 28 joints; DB, double blind; DMARDs, disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs; ESR, erythrocyte sedimentation rate; GC, glucocorticoid; HAQ, health assessment questionnaire; MC, multicenter; MTX, methotrexate; OL, open label; OR, odds ratio; pts, patients; PD, power Doppler; RCT, randomized controlled trial; SC, single center; SHS, Sharp-van der Heijde score; SOFI, signals of functional impairment; SSZ, sulfasalazine; VAS, visual analog scale; wks, weeks; yrs, years.