Table 2.
Parameter | Fluorimetric immunoassay |
ELISA | Electrochemiluminescence immunoassay | ELISA | Single Molecule array (Simoa) immunoassay |
Chemiluminescent immunoassay |
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Manufacturer | Fujirebio | Fujirebio | Roche Diagnostics | MESO scale discovery (MSD) |
IBL International | ADx Neuroscience | Quanterix | Saladax Biomedical, Inc. |
Instrument | Luminex—xMAP Technology |
Microplate reader with 450 ± 5 nm filter |
Cobas 6000 | MESO QuickPlex SQ and Sector S 600 |
TECAN Evolyzer with Plate Reader (450 nm) |
EUROIMMUN Analyzer I or I-2P |
Simoa HD-1 Analyzer |
VITROS EciQ/EciQ Immunodiagnostic System |
Solid phase | Antibody coupled to microspheres |
Antibody precoated plate |
Magnetic beads | Antibody coated carbon electrodes integrated in 96- well plate |
Antibody precoated plate |
Antibody precoated plate |
Antibody coupled to paramagnetic beads |
Streptavidin solid surface microwell |
Kit name/analyte | INNO-Bia AlzBio3 (Simultaneous quantification of Ab1–42, Tau, and p-Tau181P) |
INNOTEST β amyloid (1–42), INNOTEST hTauAg INNOTEST Phospho-Tau 181P |
Elecsys β-Amyloid (1–42), Elecsys tTau, ElecsyspTau (181P) |
Aβ Peptide Panel 1 Kit for Aβ 42, 40, and 38; MSD Multi-Spot Phospho (THR 231)/total Tau |
Aβ1–42 kit Aβ1–40 kit Total Tau kit Nonphosphorylated Tau kit |
Euroimmun Beta Amyloid (1–40), Euroimmun Beta Amyloid (1–42) Euroimmun Total Tau |
Aβ1–42 kit Aβ1–40 kit Total Tau kit |
Aβ1–42 kit Tau kit |
Sample throughput |
36–38 samples in duplicate/day |
36–38 samples in duplicate/day/ assay |
170 samples/hour | 36–40 samples in duplicate/day/assay (one 96 wells plate) |
39–40 samples in duplicate/day/assay (one 96-well plate) |
38 samples in duplicate/day/assay (one 96-well plate) |
500 samples/day | Contact manufacturer |
Reaction time | 15–19 hours | 15–19 hours | 18 minutes | 3 hours | 3.5–4 hours | 3.5 hours | No information | Less than 36 minutes |
Sample volume | 75 µL of CSF/well | Abeta 1–42; 25 µL of CSF/well Total Tau: 25 µL of CSF/well p-Tau 181P: 75 µL of CSF/well |
40 µL of CSF to be diluted 1:4 |
50 µL of diluted CSF (1:8 for Aβ and 1:4 for Tau) |
5 µL to be diluted 1:20 per analyte for Aβ1–42 and Aβ1–40, 25 µL to be diluted 1:4 for Total Tau, 50 µL to be diluted 1:2 for non-P-Tau |
15 µL of CSF, diluted for Aβ1–40 (1:21), 25 µL for Tau |
25 µL of CSF per analyte for Aβ1–42 and Aβ1–40, 37.5 µL for Tau |
80 µL per analyte |
Antibody for Aβ1–42, Aβ1–40, Aβ1–38 and Tau the capture antibody is followed by the detector antibody |
Aβ1–42: 4D7A3 and 3D6 Total Tau: AT120 and HT7 p-Tau181P: AT270 and HT7 |
Aβ1–42: 21F12 and 3D6 Total Tau: AT120 and BT2, HT7 p-Tau: HT7 and AT270 |
Biotinylated monoclonal anti- β-amyloid (X-42) and ruthenylated monoclonal anti- β-Amyloid (1-X) |
Aβ1–42: 12F4 and 6E10 or 4G8 Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–38: capture antibodies are specifically reactive to the C- terminus of Aβ1–40 and Aβ1–38, respectively, and 6E10 or 4G8 is a detector antibody Tau and phospho Tau: mouse monoclonal antibodies |
Aβ1–42: antihuman Aβ(38–42) rabbit IgG and HRP conjugated antihuman Aβ(11– 28) mouse IgG Aβ1–40: antihuman Aβ(35–40) (1A10) mouse IgG and HRP conjugated antihuman Aβ(11– 28) mouse IgG Tau: mouse monoclonal antibody specific to amino acids 160– 180 of the Tau 441 and mouse monoclonal antibody specific to Tau; Non-P-Tau: 1G2 |
Aβ1–42: 21F12 and 3D6 Aβ1–40: 2G3 and 3D6 Total Tau: Adx201 and Adx215 |
Aβ1–42: 6E10 and H31L21 Aβ1–40: no data Total Tau: capture antibody coupled to paramagnetic beads to the mid-domain of tau, detection antibody (biotinylated) to the N-terminus |
Aβ1–42: carboxy terminus and amino terminus Tau: amino acid regions 217–224 and amino acid regions 192–204 |
Quantitative range |
Aβ1–42: 51–1700 pg/mL Total Tau: 25–1400 pg/mL p-Tau181P: 9–260 pg/mL |
Aβ1–42: 62.5–4000 pg/mL Total Tau: 75–1200 pg/mL p-Tau 181P: 15.6–1000 pg/mL |
Aβ1–42: 200–1700 pg/mL |
Aβ1–42: 3.1–1271 (6E10) or 2.5–1271 (4G8) pg/mL Aβ1–40: 25–7000 pg/mL (6E10) or 20–6000 pg/mL (4G8) Aβ1–38: 60–8475 pg/mL (6E10) or 60–7500 pg/mL (4G8) Total Tau: 30–8000 pg/mL |
Aβ1–42: 7.81–125 pg/ mL Aβ1–40: 118–1880 pg/mL Tau: 25–1000 pg/ mL |
Aβ1–42: 126–2010 pg/mL Aβ1–40: 54–711 pg/mL (not corrected for dilution factor) Total Tau: 57–1462 pg/mL |
Aβ1–42 and Aβ1–40: 0–100 pg/mL Total Tau: 0.026–360 pg/mL |
Aβ1–42: 5–2000 pg/ mL Tau: 12–4000 pg/ mL |
Abbreviations: AD, Alzheimer’s disease; ELISA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; Aβ, amyloid beta.
NOTE. The data are information provided by each company regarding the briefly described Parameters as of March 10, 2015. For more detailed and updated information please contact the vendor of the immunoassay of interest, and visit their websites. Fujirebio is in the process of developing a highly automated immunoassay platform, LumiPulse, based on chemiluminescence detection, 120 tests/hour, monotest cartridges, and Luminex Corporation has been developing immunoassays for CSFAβ1–42, and t-tau, with assay linearity for Aβ1-42 and t-tau of 78 pg/mL to 12541 pg/mL and 36 pg/mL to 2068 pg/mL, respectively, and further details will become available for these two immunoassay systems in the future.