Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2015 Nov 1;70(3):e84–e93. doi: 10.1097/QAI.0000000000000783

TABLE 3.

ICERs Per TB Case or Death Averted

Strategy Alternatives Incident TB
Cases*
Incremental
Cases
Averted
Total Cost of
Program
Incremental
Cost of
Program
ICER Per
Case
Averted
TST_H6 Provide only TST-positive PLHIV with 6-mo IPT,
ART <250 cells/µL
318 $5,874,660
TST_H36 Provide only TST-positive PLHIV with 36-mo IPT,
ART <250 cells/µL
198 120 $6,068,082 $193,422 $1612
TST_H6H36 Provide 6-mo IPT for TST-negatives, 36-mo IPT for
TST-positives, ART <250 cells/µL
171 27 $6,244,913 $176,831 $6549

Total
Deaths
Incremental
Deaths
Averted
Total Cost of
Program
Incremental
Cost
of Program
ICER Per
Death
Averted

TST_H6 Provide only TST-positive PLHIV with 6-mo IPT,
ART <250 cells/µL
301 $5,874,660
TST_H36 Provide only TST-positive PLHIV with 36-mo IPT,
ART <250 cells/µL
221 80 $6,068,082 $193,422 $2,418
TST_H6H36 Provide 6-mo IPT for TST-negatives, 36-mo IPT for
TST-positives, ART <250 cells/µL
218 3 $6,244,913 $176,831 $58,944
ART500 Discontinue IPT and increase ART initiation
threshold to CD4 <500 cells/µL
171 47 $9,896,548 $3,651,635 $77,694

The current strategy ALL_H6 was dominated in the analysis and was not included in the final ICERs. ALL_H6 resulted in 321 total incident cases, 290 total deaths and $5,937,863 in total program costs.

*

Total number of new TB cases expected over the analytic horizon; excludes those diagnosed with TB at baseline.

Total number of deaths expected over the analytic horizon, including TB and all other causes.

Extended dominance occurs when the ICER of an alternative is greater than the ICER of a more effective strategy, indicating an inefficient use of resources.

§

Absolute dominance occurs when an alternative is both less effective and more costly than other alternatives.