Table 4.

Scores for all submissions across all categories. Principal Rank is derived from the Az score on the Principal category. For each method, Average Rank indicates the average of its rank across all categories. (Categories 1: Principal, 2: Small Vessels, 3: Medium Vessels, 4: Large Vessels, 5: Vessel/Airway Wall, 6: Vessel/Dense Lesion, 7: Vessel/Mucus-filled bronchi, 8: Vessel-in-lesion/Lesion, 9: Vessel/Nodules).

	Principal score		Az score for each category							As of ISBI’12		Post-ISBI’12
	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	Average rank	Principal	Average rank	Principal
Probabilistic
B	0.837	0.665	0.885	0.947	0.819	0.709	0.660	0.627	0.735	9.9	13	13.2	18
C	0.812	0.583	0.862	0.972	0.658	0.479	0.355	0.712	0.355	13.6	14	17.8	19
D	0.980	0.976	0.979	0.985	0.934	0.635	0.607	0.757	0.358	6.2	5	7.9	6
E	0.852	0.645	0.918	0.974	0.766	0.655	0.597	0.699	0.557	10.0	12	13.2	17
G	0.932	0.885	0.954	0.955	0.912	0.625	0.404	0.649	0.461	10.7	10	13.1	12
H	0.984	0.972	0.986	0.993	0.908	0.555	0.397	0.654	0.330	8.1	1	10.1	2
I	0.981	0.975	0.985	0.983	0.943	0.706	0.617	0.750	0.617	4.0	3	5.2	4
K	0.975	0.952	0.975	0.995	0.738	0.565	0.462	0.750	0.336	8.3	6	10.8	7
L	0.984	0.979	0.982	0.991	0.940	0.624	0.513	0.734	0.300	6.7	1	8.2	2
M	0.981	0.978	0.983	0.981	0.941	0.679	0.619	0.752	0.397	5.1	3	6.4	4
N	0.956	0.964	0.955	0.949	0.953	0.726	0.661	0.652	0.466	7.1	8	8.9	10
Q	0.561	0.479	0.485	0.709	0.492	0.528	0.450	0.651	0.571	14.7	18	18.9	23
Binary
F	0.739	0.444	0.766	0.981	0.544	0.510	0.276	0.790	0.385	12.9	15	16.7	20
J	0.652	0.448	0.566	0.920	0.376	0.419	0.184	0.829	0.544	14.4	17	18.4	22
O	0.737	0.500	0.742	0.947	0.556	0.554	0.236	0.779	0.580	12.7	16	16.6	21
P	0.902	0.821	0.921	0.955	0.865	0.683	0.462	0.645	0.507	10.3	11	13.1	13
Reference
R1	0.970	0.929	0.984	0.995	0.775	0.471	0.416	0.745	0.248	9.6	7	12.4	9
R2	0.946	0.933	0.946	0.957	0.948	0.792	0.707	0.730	0.788	5.9	9	7.4	11
Post-ISBI’12 submissions
S	0.986	0.977	0.986	0.994	0.944	0.667	0.595	0.654	0.439	-	-	6.2	1
T	0.972	0.943	0.983	0.987	0.900	0.58	0.509	0.763	0.287	-	-	9.9	8
U	0.863	0.781	0.848	0.951	0.851	0.712	0.677	0.646	0.659	-	-	12.0	16
V	0.874	0.673	0.950	0.982	0.794	0.480	0.364	0.696	0.281	-	-	16.0	15
W	0.879	0.693	0.953	0.976	0.845	0.583	0.495	0.766	0.367	-	-	12.2	14