Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 22;115(12):1462–1470. doi: 10.1038/bjc.2016.357

Table 4. Cardiac end points.

  12-months patients
6-months patients
  Overall In 1st 6 months In 2nd 6 months Overall In 1st 6 months In 2nd 6 months
Number of patients reporting at least one of the followinga
PERSEPHONE defined cardiac end points            
 Clinical cardiac dysfunctionb 140/1214 (12%) 102/1214 (8%) 91/1196 (8%) 105/1216 (9%) 84/1216 (7%) 62/1174 (5%)
  Symptoms of CHFc 78 55 41 53 41 22
  Signs of CHF 27 21 12 17 15 7
  New medication for cardiac disease 97 65 72 75 62 52
 Low LVEFd 146/1249 (12%) 91/1249 (7%) 101/1201 (8%) 117/1249 (9%) 96/1249 (8%) 59/1114 (5%)
 Cardiac deathe 3/1251 0/1251 0/1234f 1/1249 0/1249 0/1230f
Significant LVEF falls            
 An absolute decrease from baseline of ⩾10% to below 50% 106/1204 (9%) 63/1198 (5%) 68/1162 (6%) 89/1216 (7%) 68/1214 (6%) 43/1086 (4%)
 An LVEF<50% after a baseline of ⩾59% 68/1204 (6%) 37/1198 (3%) 47/1162 (4%) 57/1216 (5%) 46/1214 (4%) 23/1086 (2%)
Number of LVEF tests reported as low
Incidence of low LVEF testsg 305/6342 (5%) 146/3850 (4%) 159/2492 (6%) 242/5805 (4%) 155/3790 (4%) 87/2015 (4%)
 MUGA 117/1104 (11%) 61/641 (10%) 56/463 (12%) 96/959 (10%) 67/606 (11%) 29/353 (8%)
 ECHO 185/4479 (4%) 84/2475 (3%) 101/2004 (5%) 142/4119 (3%) 85/2474 (3%) 57/1645 (3%)
 Unknown 3/759 (<1%) 1/734 (<1%) 2/25 (8%) 4/727 (<1%) 3/710 (<1%) 1/17 (6%)

Abbreviations: ECHO=echocardiography; LVEF=left ventricular ejection fraction; MUGA=multi-gated acquisition.

a

Patients could experience a cardiac endpoint in both of the 6-month intervals.

b

Clinical cardiac dysfunction=symptoms of cardiac disease, or signs of congestive heart failure or new medication for cardiac disease.

c

CHF=congestive heart failure.

d

Low LVEF=LVEF<50%, or % unknown but classified on report as abnormal.

e

Four deaths have been reported with a ‘cardiac' cause (three in 12-month patients, one in 6-month patients). None occurred during the first 12 months after starting trastuzumab treatment. Three patients reported with a cardiac cause contributing to death (two of the patients on the 12-month arm, and the patient on the 6-month arm) also had widespread metastatic disease at the time of death. It is likely that only one death is potentially attributable to cardiac complications of treatment (12-month arm).

f

Denominators reduced from entire patient set due to either deaths due to non-cardiac reasons or withdrawal of consent for further follow-up within the first 6-month period.

g

Incidence of low LVEF tests out of the total number of tests in the time period.