Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 16;11(12):e0168081. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0168081

Table 3. Newcastle–Ottawa Scale for Observational Studies (cohorts).

Study Selection Comparability Outcome Total score
Denoyer et al[6] 2015 **** ** ** 8
Li et al[14] 2013 **** * ** 7
Wang et al[16] 2015 **** ** *** 9
Xia et al[17] 2016 **** ** ** 8
Xu et al[15] 2014 **** * ** 7

A higher overall score corresponds to a lower risk of bias; a score of five or less (out of nine) indicates a high risk of bias. Each * equals 1 point.