Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 20;6:37655. doi: 10.1038/srep37655

Table 2. Toxicity of five chemicals to Apis mellifera spp.: Probit estimates of oral LC50 values with 95% confidence limits in parentheses.

  Dimethoate Clothianidin Propiconazole Cadmium Arsenic
Probit calculated 48 h LC50 ± 95% CI mg/L 2.42 (1.96–2.89) 0.158 (0.089–0.227) nc 18.355 (9.082–27.629) 25.675 (22.222–29.129)
Probit calculated 96 h LC50 ± 95% CI mg/L 1.16 (0.95–1.38) 0.079 (0.059–0.010) nc 3.697 (0–11.916) 13.558 (11.999–15.116)
Probit calculated 240 h LC50 ± 95% CI mg/L 0.62 (0.46–0.77) 0.028 (0.018–0.038) nc nc 4.030 (3.314–4.745)
Probit calculated LC50 48 h: 96 h 2.08 2.00 nc 4.99 1.88
Probit calculated LC50 48 h: 240 h 3.90 5.64 nc nc 6.35
 
DEB Calculated 48 h LC50 mg/L 1.55 0.0257 1363 37.68 22.04
DEB Calculated 96 h LC50 mg/L 0.83 0.0243 738 13.80 10.36
DEB Calculated 240 h LC50 mg/L 0.54 0.0240 403 4.52 5.65
DEB Calculated 720 h LC50 mg/L 0.45 0.0240 299 1.39 4.48
DEB Calculated 2160 h LC50 mg/L 0.42 0.0240 292 0.45 4.27
DEB LD50 48 h: 240 h 2.87 1.07 3.38 8.34 3.90
DEB LD50 48 h: 720 h 3.44 1.07 4.56 27.11 4.92
DEB LD50 48 h: 2160 h 3.69 1.07 4.67 83.73 5.16

DEBtox parameter estimates for 48 h, 96 h and 240 h LC50 values are presented as estimate effects for a typical short-term laboratory bioassay (48 h, 96 h), extended duration bioassay (240 h), summer worker bee life-time (720 h) and winter bee life-time (2160h). The relative change of toxicity is estimated at the comparison of 48 h: 96 h, 48 h: 240 h for Probit and at 48 h: 240 h, 48 h: 720 h and 48 h: 2160 h for DEBtox estimated values. Values could not be calculated for tau-fluvalinate or 2,4-D as mortality levels were insufficient to establish any dose-response relationship. LC50 values varying between time-points by a factor of >5 but <20 are shown in italic font and LC50 values varying between time-points by a factor >20 are shown in bold font.