Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 20;11(12):e0168428. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0168428

Table 3. Correlation coefficients between different biofilm signals.

Growth condition Serum (anaerobe) Sucrose (anaerobe) Sucrose (aerobe)
Comparison Correlation coefficient rs B (95% CI) Correlation coefficient rs B (95% CI) Correlation coefficient rs B (95% CI)
Saliva 1 TB—GF 0.755** 0.218 (0.183–0.253) 0.905** 0.249 (0.239–0.260) 0.920** 0.259 (0.244–0.273)
TB—RF 0.574** 0.110 (0.084–0.137) 0.744** 0.052 (0.047–0.057) 0.898** 0.068 (0.063–0.074)
GF—RF 0.881** 0.569 (0.534–0.605) 0.863** 0.211 (0.196–0.225) 0.989** 0.268 (0.260–0.276)
Saliva 2 TB—GF 0.957** 0.435 (0.386–0.484) 0.936** 0.264 (0.255–0.273) 0.850** 0.264 (0.253–0.278)
TB—RF 0.900** 0.183 (0.162–0.204) 0.910** 0.056 (0.052–0.059) 0.807** 0.059 (0.055–0.063)
GF—RF 0.954** 0.418 (0.403–0.434) 0.867** 0.204 (0.188–0.221) 0.972** 0.224 (0.219–0.230)
Saliva 3 TB—GF 0.762** 0.418 (0.352–0.485) 0.922** 0.358 (0.342–0.374) 0.983** 0.267 (0.252–0.282)
TB—RF 0.730** 0.216 (0.177–0.254) 0.873** 0.091 (0.086–0.097) 0.984** 0.075 (0.069–0.080)
GF—RF 0.942** 0.519 (0.486–0.551) 0.967** 0.256 (0.247–0.264) 0.987** 0.281 (0.272–0.290)
Saliva 4 TB—GF 0.805** 0.643 (0.421–0.864) 0.903** 0.228 (0.209–0.247) 0.888** 0.320 (0.293–0.347)
TB—RF 0.507** 0.120 (0.068–0.172) 0.786** 0.046 (0.039–0.053) 0.826** 0.072 (0.064–0.080)
GF—RF 0.847** 0.212 (0.198–0.225) 0.898** 0.216 (0.203–0.228) 0.976** 0.231 (0.225–0.236)
Saliva 5 TB—GF 0.679** 0.232 (0.218–0.247) 0.767** 0.161 (0.139–0.183) 0.924** 0.267 (0.244–0.290)
TB—RF 0.635** 0.062 (0.056–0.068) 0.757** 0.027 (0.021–0.033) 0.844** 0.055 (0.048–0.062)
GF—RF 0.948** 0.274 (0.262–0.287) 0.958** 0.190 (0.177–0.203) 0.957** 0.214 (0.206–0.222)
Saliva 6 TB—GF 0.118 0.041 (-0.092–0.175) 0.122 0.296 (0.048–0.545) 0.837** 0.197 (0.174–0.221)
TB—RF -0.013 0.013 (-0.007–0.033) -0.016 0.042 (-0.013–0.097) 0.679** 0.038 (0.029–0.046)
GF—RF 0.638** 0.084 (0.054–0.114) 0.933** 0.212 (0.201–0.223) 0.948** 0.220 (0.204–0.237)
Saliva 7 TB—GF 0.932** 0.248 (0.236–0.259) 0.887** 0.256 (0.241–0.270) 0.863** 0.262 (0.246–0.278)
TB—RF 0.897** 0.052 (0.049–0.056) 0.848** 0.053 (0.049–0.057) 0.834** 0.053 (0.048–0.059)
GF—RF 0.966** 0.210 (0.201–0.220) 0.967** 0.212 (0.206–0.218) 0.966** 0.211 (0.203–0.218
Saliva 8 TB—GF 0.985** 0.330 (0.291–0.368) 0.714** 0.286 (0.265–0.308) 0.780** 0.115 (0.098–0.133)
TB—RF 0.933** 0.033 (0.029–0.036) 0.692** 0.071 (0.063–0.079) 0.734** 0.024 (0.016–0.031)
GF—RF 0.928** 0.095 (0.090–0.101) 0.983** 0.259 (0.248–0.269) 0.861** 0.252 (0.216–0.287)

The Spearman rank correlations of the relative intensity of total biofilm (TB), green fluorescence (GF) and red fluorescence (RF). B is the regression coefficient of the linear regression with its 95% Confidence Interval.

** = Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).