Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 20;16(12):2186. doi: 10.3390/s16122186

Table 9.

Main features of state-of-the-art indoor positioning systems.

System Scenario Technology Accuracy (Average Error)
LIPS [62] Buildings Wi-Fi ∼0.76 m
SDM [63] Small building (598 m2) Wi-Fi ∼3 m
OIL [64] Area with four rooms Wi-Fi Order of meters
EZ [65] Small (486 m2) and big buildings (12,600 m2) Wi-Fi ∼2 m (small) and 7 m (big)
WiGEM [66] Small (600 m2) and medium (3,250 m2) buildings Wi-Fi <8 m
WILL [67] Medium academic buildings (1,600 m2) Wi-Fi 86% room level accuracy
UnLoc [68] Different setups (largest 4,000 m2) Wi-Fi and inertial sensors ∼1.69 m
Zee [69] Medium sized building (2,275 m2) Wi-Fi ∼3 m together with EZ or Horus.
LiFS [70] Medium sized building (1,600 m2) Wi-Fi 89% room level accuracy
Walkie-Markie [71] Medium size office (3,600 m2) and shopping mall Wi-Fi ∼1.65 m
RADAR [72] Area 975 m2, more than 50 rooms Wi-Fi ∼3–5 m
Horus [73] 4th floor of the Computer Science building Wi-Fi ∼3–5 m
AiRISTA Flow [74] Asset tracking Wi-Fi ∼1 m
IZat [75] Automotive Wi-Fi, GPS, 4G ∼5 m
Ubisense [76] Smart factory UWB ∼15 cm
Dart [77] Manufacturing UWB ∼30 cm
3D-LOCUS [78] Laboratory Ultrasound ∼8 mm
Elpas [79] Healthcare and commercial IR, UHF and LF RFID ∼1 m
SpotON [80] Laboratory Active RFID ∼3 m
Topaz [81] Areas of ∼1000 m2 Bluetooth+IR 2–3 m
Landmarc [82] Laboratory Active RFID <2 m
Sparse distribution [83] Not specified Passive RFID <10 cm
GPs [84] Area of 1600 m2 (55 rooms) Active RFID ∼1.5 m
Robotics-based [85] 3rd floor of Duncan Hall at Rice University Wi-Fi ∼1.5 m
MultiLoc [86] 4th floor (more than 10 rooms) Wi-Fi ∼2.7 m
Zigbee IPS [87] Engineering building 7.26 × 16.5 m2 Zigbee ∼3.01 m
TIX [88] Office (1020 m2) Wi-Fi ∼5.4 m
BLE fingerprinting [89] Office (600 m2) BLE <2.6 m, high beacon density
GSM fingerprinting [90] Large multi-floor buildings GSM ∼5 m
NDI [91] Industry and healthcare Infrared (3D) 0.1 mm
IRIS_LPS [92] Lecture hall (100 m2) Infrared + stereo camara <16 cm
Bat [93] Building (1000 m2), three floors Ultrasound 3 cm
Cricket [94] Different rooms RF + Ultrasound 10 cm, orientation accuracy 3
Sonitor [95] Healthcare Ultrasound, Wi-Fi and LF Room level accuracy
COMPASS [96] Office building (312 m2) Wi-Fi, no real-time tracking ∼1.65 m
OPT [97] Context aware app in personal network IEEE 802.15.4 1.5–3.8 m
Easy Living [98] In-home and in-offices Multiple tech Accuracy non guaranteed
Beep [99] Room 20 × 9 m2: users can use their own devices Sound source location 0.4 cm