Skip to main content
. 2017 Jan 16;9(1):1–11. doi: 10.4253/wjge.v9.i1.1

Table 3.

Meta-analysis comparing robot-assisted gastrectomy with laparoscopic assisted gastrectomy and/or open gastrectomy in the treatment gastric cancer

Ref. Subject Patients (n)
Operation time (min)1 Blood loss (mL)1 Harvested nodes (n)1 Morbidity (%) Mortality (%) Hospital stay (d)1
RAG LAG OG
Xiong et al[56] RAG vs LAG 268 650 - 68.772 (RAG > LAG)3 -41.882 (RAG < LAG)3 -0.712 (NS) 0.744 (NS) 1.804 (NS) -0.542 (NS)
Liao et al[57] RAG vs OG 520 - 5260 65.732 (RAG > LAG)3 -126.082 (RAG < LAG)3 -0.782 (NS) 0.984 (NS) 0.984 (NS) -2.872 (RAG < LAG)3
Hyun et al[58] RAG vs LAG RAG vs OG 634 558 1236 - - 5301 61.992 (RAG > LAG)3 65.732 (RAG > OG)3 -6.082 (NS) -154.182 (RAG < OG)3 -0.252 (NS) -1.132 (NS) 1.124 (NS) 1.374 (NS) NR NR -0.602 (NS) -2.182 (RAG < OG)3
Marano et al[20] RAG vs OG RAG vs LAG 404 404 - 845 718 - 95.832 (RAG > OG)3 63.702 (RAG > LAG)3 -225.582 (NS) -35.532 (RAG < LAG)3 -2.682 (NS) 0.502 (NS) 0.934 (NS) 0.874 (NS) NR NR -2.922 (RAG < OG)3 -0.602 (NS)
Xiong et al[59] RAG vs LAG 736 1759 - 48.642 (RAG > LAG)3 -33.562 (RAG < LAG)3 1.282 (NS) 1.134 (NS) 1.664 (NS) -1.162 (NS)
Liao et al[60] RAG vs LAG 762 1473 - 50.02 (RAG > LAG)3 -46.972 (RAG < LAG)3 1.612 (NS) 0.884 (NS) 0.454 (NS) -0.52 (NS)
Shen et al[61] RAG vs LAG 506 1369 - 48.462 (RAG > LAG)3 -38.432 (RAG < LAG)3 1.062 (NS) 0.954 (NS) NR -1.02 (NS)
Zong et al[62] RAG vs OG RAG vs LAG 481 997 - 2207 4674 - 68.472 (RAG > OG)3 57.152 (RAG > LAG)3 -106.632 (RAG < OG)3 -28.592 (NS) -0.782 (NS) -0.632 (NS) 0.924 (NS) 1.064 (NS) 0.724 (NS) 1.054 (NS) -2.492 (RAG < OG)3 -0.162 (NS)
Chuan et al[63] RAG vs LAG 551 1245 - 42.92 (RAG > LAG)3 -16.072 (RAG < LAG)3 2.452 (NS) 1.054 (NS) NR -1.982 (RAG < LAG)3
1

Mean value;

2

Weighted mean difference;

3

Difference statistically significant, P < 0.05;

4

Odds ratio. RAG: Robot-assisted laparoscopic gastrectomy; LAG: Laparoscopic assisted gastrectomy; OG: Open gastrectomy; NR: Not reported; NS: Not statistically significant difference.