Table 1.
A list of published quantitative proteomics papers in the field of crop plant responses to abiotic stress factors which employ different genotypes of common crop cultivars. Columns indicate the crop plant, stress condition, genotypes compared, age of plant at end of stress treatment, duration of stress treatment, tissue studied, methods of quantitative proteomics used, number of biological replicates, type of protein sampling, and whether the proteomic results were further validated.
Crop | Stress | Genotypes | Plant Age | Stress Duration | Plant Tissue | Quant. Method a | # Biol. Reps. b | Protein Extraction | Val. c | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Corn | Drought–dehydration | CE704–tolerant, 2023–resistant | 40 days | 6 days | Leaves | iTRAQ/2DGE | NS/3 | total protein | No | [14] |
Drought–water deficit | Lc–sensitive, Io–tolerant | 3 weeks old | 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14 days | Leaves | 2DGE | 3 or 5 | total protein | No | [15] | |
UV-B irradiation | W23–sensitive, Cacahuacintle-tolerant, Confite Puneño–tolerant | 28 days | 21 days | Leaves | DIGE | 3 | total protein | Yes | [16] | |
Wheat | Drought | Excalibur-tolerant, RAC875-tolerant, Kukri-sensitive | adult plants unknown age | cyclic | Leaves | iTRAQ | 1 | total protein | No | [17] |
ABA | Nesser–tolerant, Opata–sensitive | 10 day old seedlings | 6 h | Roots | iTRAQ | 3 | total protein | Yes | [18] | |
Drought | Hanxuan10–tolerant, Chinese Spring–sensitive | seedlings | 48 h | roots, leaves and sections including leaf sheath and stem | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [19] | |
Salt 200 mM | CS–sensitive, AMP–tolerant | 7 weeks | 7 weeks | Shoots/Roots | DIGE | 3 | mitochondria | No | [20] | |
Drought, heat, salt, cold | China-108, Yennon-78, Norin-61, Kantou-107 | 4 months | N.S. | Seeds | 2DGE | 1 | total protein | No | [21] | |
Drought and salt | Shanrong 3–tolerant, Jinan 177–sensitive | seedlings | 24 h | Shoots/Roots | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [22] | |
Rice | Drought | Zhenshan97B–susceptible, IRAT109–tolerant | 50 days | 20 days | Leaves | 2DGE | NS | total protein | No | [23] |
Drought | IR62266–tolerant, CT9993–sensitive | up to 53 days | various | Leaves | 2DGE | NS | total protein | No | [24] | |
Drought | KDML105–unknown, NSG19–tolerant, IR20–sensitive | 25 days | up to 96 h | Leaves | 1DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [25] | |
Salinity 100 mM | Pokkali–tolerant, IR29–sensitive | 28 days | 14 days | Roots | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [24] | |
Nitrogen deficiency | Chunyou 58–tolerant Yongyou 6–sensitive | 4th leaf | up to 7 days | Leaves | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [26] | |
Soybean | Aluminium | PI416937–tolerant, Young–sensitive | seedlings | up to 72 h | Roots | DIGE | NS | total protein | No | [27] |
UV-B irradiation | Clark–tolerant, Magenta–sensitive | 12 days | 9 days | Seedlings | 2DGE | 5 | total protein | No | [28] | |
Salinity 150 mM | Jackson–sensitive, Lee–tolerant | 21 days | up to 144 h | Leaves | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [29] | |
Barley | Salinity 50–250 mM | Morex–tolerant, Steptoe–sensitive | seedlings | 13 days | Roots | 2DGE IPG 3–10 | 3 | total protein | yes | [30] |
Salinity 100–150 mM | Morex–tolerant, Steptoe–sensitive | seedlings | up to 16 days | Roots | 2DGE IPG 4–7 | 3 | total protein | yes | [31] | |
Salinity 300 mM | Afzal–tolerant, Line 527–sensitive | seedlings | 4 days | Leaves | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [32] | |
Salinity 300 mM | Afzal–tolerant, Line 527–sensitive | 7 weeks | 3 weeks | Leaves | 2DGE | NS | total protein | No | [33] | |
Drought | 004223–tolerant, 004186–sensitive | 6 day old seedlings | 3 days | Shoots | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [34] | |
Drought | Arta–tolerant, Keel–tolerant | 33 days | 7 days | Leaves | DIGE | 3 | total protein | No | [35] | |
Boron | DH +-tolerant, DH-–sensitive | seedlings | 2 weeks | Roots | iTRAQ | 2 | soluble protein | No | [36] | |
Drought | 15141–tolerant, 15163–sensitive | Seedlings–unknown age | 7 days | Leaves | DIGE | 3 | total protein | No | [37] | |
Brassica | Low phosphorus | 102–tolerant, 105–sensitive | 41 days | 26 days | Leaves/Roots | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [38] |
Peanut | Drought–water deficit | COC041-tolerant, COC166-sensitive | 74 days | 7 days | Leaves | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | Yes | [39] |
Sugar cane | Drought | K86-161-tolerant, KhonKhan-sensitive | 15 weeks | 21 days | Leaves | 2DGE | NS | total protein | Yes | [40] |
Strawberry | Cold | Frida-sensitive, Jonsok-tolerant | 8 weeks + hardening 2–48 days | 48 h | Crowns | 2DGE and LFQP | 3 | total protein | No | [41] |
Sugar beet | Drought | 7112 7219 | 157 days | N.S. | Leaves | 2DGE | 10 | total protein | No | [42] |
Tomato | Salinity 100 mM | Roma–tolerant, Supermarmande–sensitive | 24 days | 14 days | Leaves | 2DGE | 4 | total protein | No | [43] |
Chickpea | Drought | JG-62–tolerant, ICCV-2–sensitive | 27 days | 1–6 days | Shoots | 2DGE | 2 | nuclei | No | [44] |
Grape | Drought and Salinity (250 mM final) | Chardonnay–tolerant, Cabernet Sauvignon–sensitive | Two-year-old rooted cuttings | up to 16 days | Shoots | 2DGE | 3 | total protein | No | [45] |
Banana | Drought (sorbitol) | Mbwazirume Williams Popoulou Obino L’Ewai Cachaco | 4 week old explants | 48 days | Leaves | DIGE | 6 | total protein | No | [46] |
a Quantification method; b Number of biological replicates; c Validation; NS, Not stated in manuscript.