| Chen [2008] (5) |
116 (92 M, 24 F) |
98 Child A; 18 Child B |
92 resections of less than two segments, 19 resections greater than two segments |
II: 8 |
2 [65] |
| Cho [2008] (6) |
52 (M/F n.d.) |
48 Child A; 3 Child B; 1 Child C |
32 anterolateral segments, 20 posterosuperior segments |
I: 3, II: 2, IIIa: 5 |
n.d. |
| Yoon [2009] (7) |
69 (50 M, 19 F) |
62 Child A; 6 Child B; 1 Child C |
44 anterolateral segments, 25 posterosuperior segments (8 major resection) |
I: 15, II: 23 |
3.1±1.5 |
| Belli [2011] (8) |
65 (38 M, 27 F) |
58 Child A; 7 Child B |
23 subsegmentectomies, 17 left lateral sectionectomies, 19 segmentectomies, 6 major resection |
I: 5, II: 3, IIIb: 2, V: 1 |
3.8 (1.0–9.0) |
| Ker [2011] (9) |
116 (92 M, 24 F) |
98 Child A; 17 Child B; 1 Child C |
97 segmentectomy or less, 7 left lateral segmentectomy, 4 left lobectomy, 8 right anterior sectionectomy |
I: 7 |
2.5±1.2 |
| Yoon [2012] (10) |
107 (78 M, 29 F) |
94 Child A; 12 Child B; 1 Child C |
18 resection and/or LRFA, 46 nonanatomical resection, 12 left lateral sectionectomy, 3 left hemihepatectomy, 7 right hemihepatectomy, 19 right posterior sectionectomy, 1 right anterior sectionectomy, 1 central bisectionectomy |
I: 7, II: 11 |
3.0±1.6 |
| Kobayashi [2013] (11) |
56 (41 M, 15 F) |
48 Child A; 8 Child B |
47 partial hepatectomy (26 hybrid laparoscopic hepatecomy—21 pure laparoscopic hepatectomy), 6 segmentectomy (hybrid laparoscopic hepatecomy—3 pure laparoscopic hepatectomy) |
I: 2, IIIa: 1 |
2.0 (1.0–9.0) |
| Soubrane [2013] (12) |
361 (260 M, 91 F) |
275 Child A; 8 Child B; 1 Child C |
36 major hepatectomy (20 right hepatectomy, 14 left hepatectomy, 2 central hepatectomy), 92 left lateral sectionectomy, 83 segmentectomy, 140 wedge resection |
I: 35, II: 21, IIIa: 3, IIIb: 8, IVa: 5, IVb: 1, V: 6 |
3.5 (0.5–17.0) |
| Ai [2013] (13) |
97 (75 M, 22 F) |
59 Child A; 38 Child B |
64 segmentectomy, 24 nonanatomical resection |
I: 3, II: 7 |
7.85±2.15 |
| Long [2013] (14) |
169 (M/F n.d.) |
n.d. |
139 anterior segment, 16 posterior segmentectomy, 14 major hepatectomy |
I: 2, II: 2 |
3.73 (2.00–10.00) |
| Kim [2013] (15) |
70 (58 M, 12 F) |
n.d. |
31 wedge resection, 18 segmentectomy, 12 left lateral sectionectomy, 5 posterior sectionectomy, 2 left hepatectomy, 2 right hepatectomy |
I: 4, II: 1 |
2.58±1.44 |
| Yoon [2014] (16) |
58 (45 M, 13 F) |
53 Child A; 5 Child B |
4 right hepatectomy, 5 right posterior segmentectomy, 6 left hepatectomy, 28 left lateral segmentectomy, 15 partial hepatectomy |
I: 3, II: 1, IIIa: 1 |
2.87 (0.70–4.90) |
| Yamashita [2014] (17) |
63 (48 M, 15 F) |
59 Child A; 4 Child B |
13 left lateral segmentectomy, 1 medial segmentectomy, 5 right posterior segmentectomy, 8 subsegmentectomy (II2, III1, V1, VI2, VIII1, V + VI 1), 36 partials |
I: 2, II: 1 |
2.5±1.0 |
| Han [2015] (18) |
83 |
83 Child A |
3 right hemihepatectomy, 2 left hemihepatectomy, 14 segmentectomy, 21 left lateral sectionectomy, 43 wedge resection, 7 major liver resection, 40 anatomical liver resection |
I–II: 8, IIIa: 1, IIIb: 1 |
2.51±1.14 |
| Shehta [2015] (19) |
232 (156 M, 67 F) |
212 Child A; 16 Child B; 3 Child 3 |
195 minor resection, 37 major resection |
I: 9, IIIa: 17, IIIb: 5, V: 2 |
2.69 |
| Song [2015] (20) |
78 (70 M, 8F) |
78 Child A |
71 minor resection, 8 half hepatic resection |
I: 20, II: 2 |
n.d. |
| Ettorre [2015] (21) |
90 (67 M, 23 F) |
85 Child A; 5 Child B |
18 left lobectomy, 1 left hepatectomy, 71 segmentectomy/wedge |
I: 7, II: 9, IVa: 1 |
2.9 (0.40–10.0) |
| Takahara [2015] (22) |
118 (87 M, 31 F) |
115 Child A; 3 Child B |
23 major, 95 minor |
I: 14, II: 6, IVa: 3, V: 2 |
4.13 |
| Xiang [2015] (23) |
126 (103 M, 23 F) |
110 Child A; 16 Child B |
70 anterior segment, 56 posterior segment (24 major hepatectomy) |
n.d. |
4 |
