Table 1.
Study | Sample (T/C) | Age | Duration (year) | Symptom | Interventional time (premenstrual) | Control | Course of treatment (month) | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dong et al. 2014 [16] | 15/15 | 18~23 | NR | Q | 14 days | Acupuncture | 3 | ① |
Ren 2013 [17] | 40/40 | 16~28 | 1~8 | H | 3 days | Medicine | 3 | ① ③ |
Zhang et al. 2011 [18] | 14/14 | 15~24 | 0.5~6 | NR | 3 days | Medicine | 3 | ① ③ |
Huang 2011 [19] | 19/19 | 13~18 | 0.4~3 | NR | 5 days | Medicine | 3 | ① |
Li and Yan 2015 [20] | 50/50 | 16~27 | 2~9 | NR | 5 days | Medicine | NR | ② |
Huang and Si 2015 [21] | 38/38 | 15~27 | 0.5~5 | NR | 5 days | Medicine | 3 | ① |
Wen 2013 [22] | 30/30 | 15~36 | 1~20 | QH | 7 days | Medicine | 3 | ② |
Bai 2013 [23] | 69/64 | 13~35 | NR | QH | 7 days | Medicine | 3 | ② ③ |
Zhu and Fei 2011 [24] | 20/20 | 17~28 | 0.2~10 | H | 7 days | Medicine | 3 | ① |
Ji et al. 2011 [25] | 20/20 | 18~24 | 1~10 | NR | 7 days | Acupuncture | 3 | ① |
NR = not reported; Q = qi stagnation and blood stasis; H = cold and damp accumulation; ① = effective rate; ② = pain assessment; ③ = PGF2α levels.