Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Feb 1.
Published in final edited form as: Med Image Anal. 2016 Oct 22;36:2–14. doi: 10.1016/j.media.2016.10.005

Table 1.

The mean and standard deviation of the deformation recovery error (in voxels) when using sinusoidal simulated deformation spatially oriented along the cardinal axes. MI=mutual information, NMI=normalized mutual information, SSD=sum of squared difference, MSE=mean squared error, and CC=cross-correlation.

VABRA NMI SSD
T1w→T2w 0.223(0.366) 22.654(32.058)
[[T1w,T2^w][T1^w,T2w]
0.210(0.342) 0.150(0.243)
[T1¯w,T2^w][T1^w,T2¯w]
0.112(0.187) 0.142(0.248)
[T1w, T2w]⇒[T1w, T2w] 0.222(0.366) 0.124(0.205)
Elastix MI MSE
T1w→T2w 0.135(0.229) 15.896(22.551)
[T1w,T2^w][T1^w,T2w]
0.132(0.216) 0.185(0.321)
[T1¯w,T2^w][T1^w,T2¯w]
0.144(0.244) 0.196(0.333)
[T1w, T2w]⇒[T1w, T2w] 0.105(0.220) 0.122(0.171)
SyN MI MSE CC
T1w→T2w 0.179(0.299) 1.851(2.969) 0.577(0.962)
[T1w,T2^w][T1^w,T2w]
0.138(0.232) 0.167(0.277) 0.147(0.246)
[T1¯w,T2^w][T1^w,T2¯w]
0.145(0.248) 0.221(0.359) 0.160(0.271)
[T1w, T2w]⇒[T1w, T2w] 0.134(0.229) 0.150(0.256) 0.126(0.215)