Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Feb 10.
Published in final edited form as: J Am Chem Soc. 2016 Aug 2;138(31):9826–9839. doi: 10.1021/jacs.6b02382

Table 1. Evaluating the Consistency of the MD Simulations with Experimental Observations.

no. experiment experimental observation observation from optimized force field (unoptimized force field) comments
1a CD/NMR of Im76–45 by itself 11%/21% helicity 15% helicity (unoptimized: 10%) this is the only observation that was used to optimize the individual force fields
2a CD of Spy:Im76–45, subtracting CD spectrum of Spy alone 40% helicity of Im76–45 while in complex with Spy 36% helicity of Im76–45 while in complex with Spy (unoptimized: 23%) increased agreement after optimization
3a CD of Spy:Im76–45 +29 pp change in Im7645 helicity upon bindingb +21 pp change in Im76–45 helicity upon binding (unoptimized: +13 pp) calculated from observations 1 and 3; increased agreement after optimization
4a NMR titrations of Spy:Im76–45 see Figure 2 for per-residue intensity decreases of Spy similar patterns observed in the frequency of contact between Spy and Im76–45 see the Contact Maps section in Supporting Methods and Figure S8
5c X-ray crystallography 51% of residues on the concave surface of Spy participate in Im76–45 binding, compared to 12% of residues in other regions 51% of residues on the concave surface of Spy participate in Im76–45 binding, compared to 2% of residues in other regions (unoptimized: 31%/2%) See the Interaction Patterns section in Supporting Methods and Figure S7
6c X-ray crystallography Spy dimer twists by −9° upon Im76–45 binding, as defined by an interdomain dihedral angle Spy dimer twists, on average, by −4.6° along this same dihedral angle while bound to Im76–45 intramolecular Spy force field is the same in the optimized and unoptimized simulations, Figure 4
7c X-ray crystallography flexible linker region (residues 47–57) more disordered upon Im76–45 binding upon binding, per-residue fluctuations increased by ∼50% relative to the unbound state for several residues in the flexible linker region see comment for observation 6, Figure 4
8d kinetics of Im7 folding while bound to Spy binding to Spy slows down both folding and unfolding of full-length Im76–45 by approximately an order of magnitude binding to Spy slows down folding (by a factor of 2) and unfolding (by a factor of 5) of the Im76–45 substrate network analysis only performed for the optimized simulations, Figure 5
9e genetic selections to increase Spy chaperone activity mutants either increase concave surface hydrophobicity, or potentially increase flexibility of linker region binding occurs primarily within cradle, and flexible linker region increases motion in bound state see Site-Specific Description of Chaperone–Substrate Interactions
10e in vitro cross-linking of Spy and Im7645 all cross-links indicate binding to concave surface see item 5 above
11e in vitro H/D exchange and proteolysis of Spy upon Im76–45 binding several residues on Spy's concave surface are protected upon binding Spy interacts with Im7645 through its concave surface see Site-Specific Description of Chaperone–Substrate Interactions
a

This study.

b

pp = percentage points.

c

Ref 11.

d

Ref 13.

e

Ref 9.