Skip to main content
. 2017 Jan 19;12(1):e0170258. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0170258

Table 1. Base case estimates, range, and distribution for model variables.

Variable Base case value Range Distribution Standard deviation References
Probabilities
 Oral vancomycin pulse/taper—cure 0.771 0.652–0.890 Beta 0.061 [8,49]
 Oral vancomycin pulse/taper—relapse 0.568 0.408–0.727 Beta 0.081 [8,49]
 Fidaxomicin—cure 0.812 0.719–0.904 Beta 0.047 [2125,50,51]
 Fidaxomicin—relapse 0.211 0.105–0.316 Beta 0.054 [2125,50,51]
 FMT colonoscopy—cure 0.894 0.852–0.937 Beta 0.022 [8,5258]
 FMT colonoscopy—relapse 0.022 0.001–0.043 Beta 0.011 [8,5258]
 FMT colonoscopy after second FMT—cure 0.563 0.319–0.806 Beta 0.124 [8,52,5557]
 FMT duodenal infusion—cure 0.795 0.723–0.867 Beta 0.037 [7,26,59,60]
 FMT duodenal infusion—relapse 0.021 0.000–0.049 Beta 0.014 [7,26,59,60]
 FMT duodenal infusion after second FMT—cure 0.750 0.326–1.174 Beta 0.217 [7,26]
 FMT enema—cure 0.833 0.712–0.955 Beta 0.062 [6163]
 FMT enema—relapse 0.000 0.000–0.000 Beta 0.000 [6163]
 FMT enema after second FMT—cure 0.500 0.100–0.900 Beta 0.204 [61,63]
 Severe uncomplicated CDI 0.180 0.115–0.246 Beta 0.033 [64]
 Severe complicated CDI 0.012 0.011–0.013 Beta 0.001 [36,64]
 Colectomy 0.318 0.293–0.344 Beta 0.013 [36,37]
 Postcolectomy mortality 0.407 0.350–0.463 Beta 0.029 [37,6567]
 Adverse events of FMT colonoscopy 0.002 0.000–0.012 Beta 0.005 [2729]
 Adverse events of FMT duodenal infusion 0.0005 0.000–0.002 Beta 0.0007 [31]
 Mortality from FMT colonoscopy 0.0003 0.0002–0.0003 Beta 0.00003 [2830,68]
 Mortality from FMT duodenal infusion 0.0002 0.000–0.0004 Beta 0.0001 [31]
 Hospitalization for mild CDI 0.000 0.000–0.000 Beta 0.000 Expert opinion
 Mortality from mild CDI 0.007 0.002–0.012 Beta 0.002 [69,70]
 Mortality from severe uncomplicated CDI 0.339 0.221–0.457 Beta 0.060 [71]
Costsa
 Oral vancomycin pulse/taperb 58 not varied Local sources
 Fidaxomicin (200 mg bid, 10 days) 1416 not varied Local sources
 Oral vancomycin (500 mg qid, 10 days) 50 not varied Local sources
 Intravenous metronidazole (500 mg tid, 10 days) 11 not varied Local sources
 Outpatient visit 43 not varied Local sources
 Donor and stool testing prior to FMT 825 not varied NABM
 Stool transplant preparation and traceability of samples 154 not varied Local sources
 Oral vancomycin (500 mg qid, 4 days) prior to FMT 20 not varied Local sources
 FMT delivery by colonoscopy 289 not varied Local sources
 FMT delivery by duodenal infusion 76 not varied Local sources
 FMT delivery by enema 5 not varied Local sources
 Follow-up outpatient visits 86 not varied Local sources
 Mean cost of hospitalization for mild-to-moderate CDI 2190 2099–2280 Gamma 45 [46]
 Mean cost of hospitalization for severe CDI 8412 7725–9098 Gamma 343 [46]
 Colectomy 719 not varied CCAM
 Adverse events of FMT colonoscopy 283 not varied CCAM
 Adverse events of FMT duodenal infusion 229 not varied CCAM
Utilities
 Severe CDI (complicated or uncomplicated) 0.600 0.505–0.695 Beta 0.156 [47]
 Mild-to-moderate CDI 0.782 0.628–0.936 Beta 0.154 [48]
 Postcolectomy 0.536 0.382–0.690 Beta 0.154 [72]
 Adverse events of FMT colonoscopy or FMT duodenal infusion 0.770 0.670–0.920 Beta 0.154 [73]
 Healthy 1
 Death 0

Abbreviations: bid: twice daily; CCAM: French Common Classification of Medical Procedures; CDI: Clostridium difficile infection; FMT: fecal microbiota transplantation; NABM: French Nomenclature of Procedures in Laboratory Medicine; IV: intravenous; od: once daily; qid: 4 times daily; tid: 3 times daily.

aCosts are reported as 2016 Euros.

bOral vancomycin pulse/taper: oral vancomycin at 125 mg qid for 10 days, then 500 mg od every 2 days for 21 days.