Table 1.
Steps of a Systematic Review | Considerations for a Network Meta-analysis |
---|---|
1. Define the review question and eligibility criteria | - Question should benefit from network meta- analysis - Define the treatment network |
2. Search for and select studies | - Ensure search is broad enough to capture treatments of interest |
3. Abstract data and assess risk of bias | - Abstract information on potential effect modifiers which may violate the assumption of transitivity |
4. Synthesize evidence qualitatively | - Evaluate the network geometry - Evaluate transitivity |
5. Synthesize evidence quantitatively | - Conduct pairwise meta-analyses first - Use statistical models appropriate for network meta-analysis - Evaluate inconsistency - Summarize results using approaches suitable for network meta-analysis, such as league tables - If ranking, use appropriate ranking statistics, such as SUCRA |
6. Interpret results and draw conclusions | - Carefully interpret results, especially rankings - Interpret results in context of outcomes examined - If using GRADE approach to evaluate quality of evidence, adapt for network meta-analysis |
7. Report findings | - Follow the PRISMA extension for network meta- analysis |