Skip to main content
. 2017 Jan 20;12(1):e0170244. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0170244

Table 3. Species with discordant BINs found by the ‘BIN Discordance Report’ sequence analysis tool on BOLD.

Taxonomic ranks of conflict are reported including species of the same genus up to taxa belonging to different orders. The column BIN Taxon Variation shows the number of records for each taxon in parenthesis.

Species Discordant BIN Rank of conflict BIN Taxon Variation After review
Dasyatis pastinaca 1 BOLD:ACK8259 Family Dasyatidae[20], Rhinobatidae[1] Concordant
Squalus blainville BOLD:AAA1550 Family Squalidae[131], Centrophoridae[1] Concordant
Prionace glauca BOLD:AAA7096 Genus Prionace[68], Carcharhinus[1] Concordant
Dasyatis centroura BOLD:AAD5044 Species Dasyatis ushiei[7], Dasyatis centroura[7] Discordant
Dasyatis pastinaca 2 BOLD:AAD5036 Species Dasyatis tortonesei[6], Dasyatis pastinaca[4] Discordant
Mobula mobular BOLD:AAB8636 Species Mobula japanica[27], Mobula mobular[2], Mobula sp.[1], Mobula japonica[1] Discordant
Dipturus oxyrinchus BOLD:ABZ4263 Species Dipturus oxyrinchus sp1[56], Dipturus oxyrinchus[49] Concordant
Raja brachyura BOLD:AAA4358 Species Raja brachyura[36], Raja sp.[1] Concordant
Raja clavata BOLD:ACF2419 Species Raja clavata[107], Raja undulata[1] Concordant
Raja polystigma BOLD:ABY6158 Species Raja polystigma[24], Raja sp.[1] Concordant
Torpedo nobiliana BOLD:AAC6970 Species Torpedo nobiliana[9], Torpedo macneilli[5], Torpedo fairchildi[4], Torpedo tokionis[1], Torpedo sp. A[1] Discordant
Mustelus mustelus BOLD:AAA4345 Species Mustelus mustelus[72], Mustelus sp.[3] Concordant
Mustelus punctulatus BOLD:AAA4347 Species Mustelus punctulatus[164], Mustelus sp. zpl 00058[1] Concordant
Centrophorus granulosus BOLD:AAB4327 Species Centrophorus granulosus[59], Centrophorus zeehaani[28], Centrophorus lusitanicus[1] Discordant
Oxynotus centrina BOLD:AAF2493 Species Oxynotus centrina[8], Oxynotus paradoxus[1] Concordant
Centroscymnus coelolepis BOLD:AAB8284 Species Centroscymnus coelolepis[20], Centroscymnus sp.[1] Concordant
Squalus acanthias BOLD:AAA1547 Species Squalus acanthias[242], Squalus suckleyi[32] Discordant