Table 1.
Technique | Age range | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Modified GAD or GAD | All age ranges | Suitable for infants and small children who are not yet old enough to cooperate with more active techniques | Discomfort, time consuming, symptoms of gastro-esophageal reflux or breathlessness, specific contraindications or precautions |
Option for those unable to use or too fatigued to use independent techniques | |||
Percussion and vibrations | All age ranges | Suitable for infants and small children who are not yet old enough to cooperate with more active techniques | Passive, require assistant, discomfort, inconvenient, socially limiting |
Option for those unable to use or too fatigued to use independent techniques | |||
Assisted autogenic drainage | Infants | Minimal equipment required | Requires assistance, difficult technique to master and for carers to learn |
Bouncing on a fitball | Infant to toddler | Enjoyable for child | Equipment required |
Blowing games | Toddler to child | Enjoyable for child | |
Huffing | Toddler to adolescent | Enjoyable for child | |
ACBT (includes huffing) | Toddler to adolescent | Independent, flexible, requires no equipment, can be combined with other techniques | |
Bottle PEP | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, enjoyable for child, can be a bridge to other forms of PEP therapy, minimal cost | Need to follow instructions to avoid swallowing water |
Autogenic drainage | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, nil equipment required | Effect and feedback required to master the technique including sensitivity to auditory and vibratory cues of secretions |
PEP mask | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, can be combined with other ACTs, beneficial for those with unstable or compliant airways | Infant PEP requires assistance. Requires individual awareness of breath size |
For younger children who are afraid of a mask, this may not be the technique of choice | |||
Cost | |||
Mouthpiece PEP | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, can be combined with other ACTs, beneficial for those with unstable or compliant airways | No clear evidence on use of Mouthpiece PEP—either with or without nose clip Cost |
Can be used in conjunction with hypertonic saline nebulizer (see below) | |||
Easy for younger children to use | |||
PariPEP™ with nebulizer | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, can be combined with other ACTs, beneficial for those with unstable or compliant airways | Cost |
Flutter® | Child to adolescent | Independent technique | Effective use dependent on angle, therefore, may be more suited to an older child (8 years). Cost |
Acapella® | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, can be combined with other ACTs, beneficial for those with unstable or compliant airways | Cost |
Not position dependent | |||
Aerobika™ | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique, can be used in conjunction with nebulizer | Cost |
Physical exercise | Toddler to adolescent | Enjoyable for child | |
HFCWO | Toddler to adolescent | Independent technique | Heavy device, not easily portable |
Cost |
GAD, gravity-assisted drainage; ACBT, active cycle of breathing technique; PEP, positive expiratory pressure; ACT, airway-clearance technique; HFCWO, high-frequency chest wall oscillations.