Table 1. Amalgamation of the osseous, vascular, and cartilage classification systems for the assessment and treatment of Kienböck disease.
Assessment | Treatment | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Osseous (Lichtman) | Vascular (Schmitt) | Cartilage (Bain) | Description | Principle | Procedure | |
B1: Lunate intact | Lunate protection | |||||
0, I, II | A | 0 | Intact lunate | Unload lunate Venous decompression Revascularization |
Immobilize, unloading procedures Lunate decompression Vascularized bone grafta |
|
B2: Lunate compromised | Lunate reconstruction | |||||
IIIA | B | 1 | Proximal lunate collapse | Lunate reconstruction | MFTGa, PRC, (RSL fusion, lunate replacementa) | |
B3: Lunate unreconstructable | Lunate salvage | |||||
IIIC | C | 2b | Lunate collapse | Lunate excision | Lunate replacementa, capitate lengthening, PRC | |
C1–3: Wrist compromised | Wrist reconstruction | |||||
IIIA | B | 2a | RC joint compromised | Fuse or bypass RL joint | RSL fusiona, SC fusion | |
IIIA or C | B | 3, 4 | RC and MC joint compromised | Bypass central column | SC fusion, hemiarthroplastya | |
IIB | B | 2–4 | Carpal collapse, (RSA > 60 degrees) | Stabilize radial column | SC fusion | |
C4: Wrist not reconstructable | Wrist salvage | |||||
IV, KDAC | C | 4 | Pan–OA | Salvage | Wrist fusion, wrist arthroplastya |
Abbreviations: KDAC, Kienböck disease advanced collapse; MC, midcarpal; MFTG, medial femoral trochlear graft; Pan–OA, pan carpal osteoarthritis; PRC, proximal row carpectomy; RC, radiocarpal; RL, radiolunate; RSA, radioscaphoid angle; RSL, radioscapholunate; SC, scaphocapitate.
Source: Lichtman et al.43
Notes: Better prognosis: Age < 15 years nonoperative, 16–20 years consider unloading, > 70 years consider synovectomy or unloading procedure. Lunate unloading procedures: Negative ulnar variance: Radial shortening osteotomy; physis intact: Radial epiphysiodesis; neutral or positive ulnar variance: Capitate shortening. Adjunctive procedures: Synovectomy, scaphotrapeziotrapezoid pinning.
Alternative procedures: Used in specialist clinics or in selected cases where the patient has failed less-invasive procedures.