Table 3.
Research | Subject characteristics | Kick | Kicking deficit† | RI | VB (m·s-1) Dominant | VB (m·s-1) Non-Dominant | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
n | Age Instep | Player level | ||||||
Narici et al. (1988) | 11 | 25.1±5.0 | Amateur | 11.5 | ARS | 20.0 ± 3.6*** | 17.7± 2.2*** | |
McLean and Tumilty (1993) | 20 | 16.8±0.7 | Elite junior | Drive kick | 16.45 | R | 21.95±1.67* | 18.34±1.39* |
Mognoni et al. (1994) | 24 | NA | Junior | 9.32 | 23.6±2.5 | 21.4±2.6 | ||
Barfield. (1995) | 18 | NA | Expert | 7.95 | R | 26.4±2.1 | 24.3±2.0 | |
Dörge et al. (2002) | 30 | Skilled | 12.95 | R | 24.7±2.5* | 21.5±2.0* | ||
Barfield et al. (2002) | 8 | 19-22 | Élite | Instep | 2C | *** | *** | |
2 | Male | 6.71 | 25.3±1.51*** | 23.6±1.57*** | ||||
6 | Female | 12.09 | 21.5±2.44*** | 18.9±2.05*** | ||||
Vaverka et al. (2003) | 12 | 15.7±0.4 | Skilled | 15.14 | 3D | 27.68±1.32 | 23.49±2.05 | |
Nunome (2006a) | 5 | 16.8±0.4 | Skilled | Instep | 15.58 | 3C | 32.1±1.7* | 27.1±1.2* |
Sedano et al. (2009b) | 10 | 22.8±2.1 | Elite female | Pre-Trained | 16.45 | R | 19.45±0.7* | 16.25±0.45* |
Post-Trained | 15.45 | 21.75±0.58* | 18.39±0.64* | |||||
Berjan et al. (2012) | 106 | 11.514.5 | Elite young | Instep | R | |||
27 | 12.2±0.3 | Maximal | 13.21 | 22.7±2.5* | 19.7±2.3* | |||
26 | 13.1±0.2 | Maximal | 18.15 | 24.8±2.1* | 20.3±2.7* | |||
26 | 14.3±0.3 | Maximal | 14.76 | 27.1±2.8* | 23.1±2.9* | |||
27 | 15.3±0.3 | Maximal | 14.63 | 28.7±2.3* | 24.5±3.1* | |||
Barbieri et al. (2015) | 10 | 21.8±2.2 | Amateur futsal | Instep | 10.91 | 3D | 24.27±2.21*** | 21.62±2.26*** |
Note: n = Sample size; RI = Register instrument; R=Radar;
ARS = Audio recording system; C = Video camera; 3D = Motion capture system; VB= Kicking ball velocity; NA= No available data;
Statistical significance: ** p < 0.01
Kicking deficit is calculated from the total average reported by those studies
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.05
p < 0.00;
p < 0.00;