Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2017 Jan 25.
Published in final edited form as: J Chem Theory Comput. 2015 Dec 11;12(1):332–344. doi: 10.1021/acs.jctc.5b00874

TABLE III.

Solvation free energies in kcal/mol from QM/MM-NBB and MESS-E-QM/MM NBB calculations using M06-2X/6-31G*. MSE’ and RMSE’ are computed for molecules 2 through 21, against full QM/MM-NBB results (column 2).

molecule QM/MM-NBB MESS-E-QM/MM-NBB
1 −22.22±0.44 −22.04±0.42
2 −4.18±0.10 −4.27±0.13
3 −7.52±0.07 −7.47±0.08
4 −7.21±0.23 −7.09±0.25
5 −6.76±0.53 −6.51±0.46
6 −10.87±0.62 −10.37±0.51
9 −10.57±0.98 −10.27±0.91
10 −6.85±0.20 −6.70±0.19
11 −9.23±0.37 −9.10±0.38
12 −5.31±0.19 −5.25±0.20
13 −6.63±0.21 −6.52±0.21
14 −5.15±0.30 −5.29±0.36
15 −6.45±0.25 −6.53±0.30
16 −5.04±0.30 −5.07±0.30
17 −4.34±0.19 −4.49±0.21
19 −5.23±0.23 −5.05±0.21
20 −3.70±0.29 −3.64±0.30
21 −10.04±0.32 −9.95±0.38
22 −10.19±0.20 −10.09±0.18
23 −6.39±0.27 −6.33±0.27
24 −7.35±0.25 −7.48±0.28
MSE’ 0.09
RMSE’ 0.18