Table 1. Characteristics of the included studies.
Source | Country | Intervention | Histology | Study design | Study period | Follow-up period | Quality score* | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
LEEP | CKC | |||||||
Munro 2015 [10] | Austria | 107 | 231 | ACIS | retrospective study | 2001 to 2012 | <1 year to 11.8 years | 9 |
Latif 2015 [2] | USA | 30 | 48 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1997 to 2011 | 2–168 months | 9 |
Baalbergen 2015 [17] | Netherlands | 45 | 65 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1989 to 2012 | 1–217 months | 8 |
Taylor 2014 [18] | USA | 15 | 37 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1998 to 2011 | mean 32 months | 7 |
Costales 2013 [12] | USA | 62 | 110 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1983 to 2011 | 0.3–286.5 months | 7 |
Hanegem 2012 [14] | USA | 54 | 58 | ACIS | retrospective | 1998 to 2010 | 3–145 months | 9 |
Kietpeerakool 2012 [13] | Thailand | 34 | 20 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1998 to 2010 | 10–144 months | 7 |
Costa 2012 [19] | Italy | 60 | 74 | ACIS | retrospective study | 2004 to 2011 | mean 40.9 months | 9 |
DeSimone 2011 [20] | USA | 17 | 24 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1990 to 2005 | 40 months | 7 |
Bull-Phelps 2007 [21] | USA | 32 | 69 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1993 to 2001 | 4–148 months | 8 |
Hwang 2004 [22] | Canada | 23 | 20 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1980 to 2002 | 1–248 months | 6 |
Kennedy 2002 [23] | USA | 30 | 27 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1994 to 2001 | 1–165 months | 8 |
Soutter 2001 [24] | UK | 43 | 10 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1986–2000 | 0–543 weeks | 6 |
Kuohung 2000 [25] | USA | 9 | 39 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1990 to 1999 | NA | 6 |
Azodi 1999 [26] | USA | 8 | 25 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1988 to 1996 | mean 38 months | 9 |
Denehy 1997 [27] | USA | 13 | 24 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1980 to 1996 | 1–72 months | 6 |
Wolf 1996 [28] | USA | 7 | 47 | ACIS | retrospective study | 1984 to 1993 | 17–132 months | 9 |
Widrich 1996 [29] | USA | 18 | 24 | ACIS | retrospectivestudy | 1980 to 1994 | 3–177 months | 7 |
* Quality assessment based on the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.
NA, not available.