Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 1;7:41262. doi: 10.1038/srep41262

Table 3. Predictive performances (prediction R 2 in %) of the standard PRS and four other PRS schemes in simulations using real genotype data (a mixture small and large effects simulated).

% casual h2 Type Standard Tdr Tweedie Tweedie*tdr LDpred
0.1% 10% max 0.700 0.962 0.951 0.925 0.705
all SNPs 0.044 0.644 0.165 0.903 0.055
0.1% 20% max 2.497 2.712 2.669 2.922 3.192
all SNPs 0.072 2.025 0.178 2.909 0.041
0.1% 30% max 6.622 6.800 6.627 7.079 7.376
all SNPs 0.411 4.342 2.852 7.079 0.489
0.1% 40% max 7.327 8.289 8.522 8.846 7.743
all SNPs 0.265 5.048 2.634 8.790 0.817
0.25% 10% max 0.921 1.154 1.269 1.328 0.986
all SNPs 0.075 0.864 0.237 1.327 0.162
0.25% 20% max 2.381 2.446 2.342 2.432 0.913
all SNPs 0.038 2.099 0.320 2.416 0.038
0.25% 30% max 2.015 2.469 2.328 2.571 2.805
all SNPs 0.730 1.899 1.268 2.571 0.653
0.25% 40% max 4.762 5.328 5.218 5.333 5.737
all SNPs 0.910 3.707 2.882 5.333 1.136
1.0% 10% max 0.695 0.800 0.773 0.766 0.374
all SNPs 0.069 0.498 0.102 0.740 0.056
1.0% 20% max 1.439 1.513 1.350 1.206 1.253
all SNPs 0.042 0.915 0.132 1.153 0.040
1.0% 30% max 3.018 3.189 3.274 3.369 2.656
all SNPs 0.274 3.189 1.059 3.367 0.730
1.0% 40% max 2.906 3.104 3.011 3.407 3.404
all SNPs 0.599 2.147 1.565 3.407 1.178
2.5% 10% max 0.730 0.934 0.982 1.007 0.960
all SNPs 0.035 0.387 0.112 0.977 0.046
2.5% 20% max 1.912 2.106 2.096 2.045 2.132
all SNPs 0.352 1.452 0.797 2.045 0.338
2.5% 30% max 1.269 1.398 1.440 1.482 1.712
all SNPs 0.353 0.972 0.648 1.482 0.324
2.5% 40% max 2.691 2.861 2.787 2.925 3.651
all SNPs 0.706 2.043 1.554 2.924 0.605

A mixture of small and large effects was simulated as described in the main text. The best performing PRS weighting method in each scenario is in bold. % causal: percentage of causal markers; h2: total heritability explained by panel markers. For all methods except LDpred, we first applied LD-clumping with an r2 threshold of 0.25 to all SNPs. “Max” refers to the maximum prediction R2 achieved after optimizing over a range of p-value thresholds or fractions of causal variants. “All.SNPs” refers to the predictive performance using all SNPs after LD-clumping, except for LDpred where no clumping was performed. All predictive performances were measured by R2 in %.