Skip to main content
. 2017 Jan 19;8(1):e216. doi: 10.1038/ctg.2016.66

Table 1. Characteristic of included studies.

NO Study Year Country Sample size TP TN FP FN Cut-off value Algorithm Study type Assay method Kit used
1 Yu D 2015 China 123 57 46 7 13 Ct<45. 0 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
2 Jin P 2015 China 476 101 298 43 34 Ct<45. 0 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
3 He Q 2015 China 100 38 48 2 12 PMR≥ 4% NA Case–control MethyLight NA
4 He N 2015 China 281 54 196 9 22 Ct<40. 5 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
5 Wang Z 2012 China 56 25 18 2 11 PMR≥1% NA Case–control MS-HRM NA
6 Li SJ 2015 China 161 66 65 5 25 NA 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
7 Wu D 2016 China 1031 223 697 43 68 Ct<45. 0 1(1) Prospective study RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
8 Kang Q 2014 China 132 60 51 1 20 NA 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
9 Ding QQ 2015 China 262 60 171 9 22 Ct<45. 0 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
10 Warren JD 2011 US, Russia 144 38 93 1 12 Ct<45. 0 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
    2011 USA, Russia 144 45 83 11 5 Ct<41. 0 1(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
    2011 USA, Russia 144 35 94 0 15 Ct<45. 0 3(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
11 Johnson DA 2014 USA 301 74 163 37 27 NA NA Prospective study RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
12 Lee HS 2013 Korea 197 37 87 9 64 NA 1(3) Case–control RT-PCR Abbott Molecular
13 Lucia PC 2014 USA 367 244 20 1 102 NA NA Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
14 Marc T 2010 Germany 161 24 98 30 9 NA 2(3) Case–control Heavy MethyLight NA
    2010 Germany 161 27 81 47 6 NA 1(3) Case–control Heavy MethyLight NA
15 Grutzmann R 2008 Germany 831 193 403 50 185 NA 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
16 deVos T 2009 Germany 514 138 282 45 49 3.4ug/L 1(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
    2009 Germany 514 105 316 11 82 3.4ug/L 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
17 Church TR 2013 Germany, USA 1510 27 1331 126 26 Ct<50 1(2) Prospective study RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0
18 Toth K 2012 Hungary 184 73 91 1 19 Ct<40. 5 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
    2012 Hungary 184 88 78 14 4 Ct<40. 5 1(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
19 Toth K 2014 Hungary 84 30 40 10 4 PMR≥ 0.01% NA Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
20 Su XL 2014 China 234 152 58 4 20 MSP≥1% NA Case–control MSP-DHPLC NA
21 Potter NT 2014 USA 1544 30 1182 318 14 Ct<45. 0 1(3) Prospective study RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
22 Lofton-Day C 2008 USA 312 92 154 25 41 NA NA Case–control MethyLight NA
23 He Q 2010 China 352 136 164 6 46 PMR≥ 4% NA Case–control MethyLight NA
24 Ørntoft MW 2015 Denmark 470 93 282 60 35 Ct<45. 0 1(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
    2015 Denmark 470 75 328 14 53 Ct<45. 0 2(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 2.0
25 Ahlquist DA 2011 USA 100 18 54 16 12 Ct<45. 0 1(3) Case–control RT-PCR Epipro Colon 1.0

MS-HRM, methylation sensitive high-resolution melting; MSP-DHPLC, methylation spective polymerase chain reaction; RT-PCR, real-time polymerase chain reaction.