Table 1.
Author (Year) | Study design | Geographic area | Industry type | Fiber type | Outcome identification | Asbestos | Smoking | NOS | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Data collection | Exposure Identification | Non exposed | Exposed | Data collection | Non Smoker | Smoker | |||||||
Berry (1985) [24] | Prospective | East London (UK) | Asbestos factory | Undetermined | Register | Employment record | Expert | Light and moderate | Severe | Questionnaire | Never | Ever | 6 |
Liddell (2002) [26] | Prospective | Quebec (Canada) | Mining and Milling | Chrysotile | Death certificate | Employment record | Measures | <30 mpcf.y | ≥30 mpcf.y | Questionnaire | Never | Ever | 7 |
Reid (2006) [23] | Prospective | Wittenoom (Australia) | Mining and Milling | Crocidolite | Register | -Questionnaire -Employment record |
Measures | Low | High | Questionnaire | Never and former >20 Y | Current and former <20 Y | 8 |
Frost (2011) [25] | Prospective | Great Britain | Different types | Undetermined | Register | Questionnaire | Expert | <10 Y | ≥30 Y | Questionnaire | Never | Current | 8 |
Wang (2012) [22] | Prospective | Qinghai (China) | Mining and Milling | Chrysotile | Death certificate | Employment record | Measures | Non miners and millers | Miners and millers | Interview | Never | Ever | 6 |
Wang (2012) [28] | Prospective | China | Asbestos factory | Chrysotile | Death certificate | -Employment record -Questionnaire |
Measures | Electronics factory | Asbestos cohort | Questionnaire | Never | Ever | 7 |
Offermans (2014) [27] | Case-cohort | Netherlands | Undetermined | Undetermined | Register | Questionnaire | Matrix | Never | Ever | Questionnaire | Never | Current | 7 |
NOS the Newcastle-Ottawa quality assessment Scale, S current smokers, mpcf.y million particles per cubic foot x years, Y years