Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 20;173(2):1247–1257. doi: 10.1104/pp.16.01045

Table I. Determination of nonadditive expression classes in reciprocal maize hybrids under control and water deficit conditions.

Classa Expression Pattern Criteria
Total No. of Genes
No. of Nonadditive Genesb
LP ≠ H HP ≠ H LP ≠ HP B73xMo17
Overlapc
Mo17xB73
Overlapc
B73xMo17
Overlapc
Mo17xB73
Overlapc
C WD E O C WD E O C WD E O C WD E O
1 LP < H < HP Y Y Y 3,783 3,109 440 2,398* 3,325 3,187 396 2,351* 1,179 1,196 53 829* 1,154 1,119 48 832*
2 LP = H < HP Y Y Y 3,175 3,751 445 1,519* 4,400 3,724 613 2,110* 581 1,475 32 209* 1,556 1,273 74 508*
3 LP < H = HP Y N Y 5,845 5,599 1,224 3,179* 5,856 5,276 1,156 3,468* 1,437 3,180 171 754* 3,254 2,207 269 1,309*
4 LP = HP = H N N N 8,559 7,224 2,313 4,821* 6,960 8,555 2,227 4,839* 3 84 0 0 55 44 0 0
5 LP < HP < H Y Y Y 47 267 0 9* 148 65 0 17* 47 267 0 9* 148 65 0 17*
6 LP = HP < H Y Y N 199 641 5 81* 342 259 3 92* 199 641 5 81* 342 259 3 92*
7 H < LP < HP Y Y Y 134 343 2 49* 260 265 3 72* 134 343 2 49* 260 265 3 72*
8 H < LP = HP Y Y N 430 1,202 19 189* 1,022 813 31 322* 430 1,202 19 189* 1,022 813 31 322*
9 Ambiguous 4,565 4,601 786 1,158* 4,424 4,593 760 1,225* 539 1,756 35 72* 1,439 1,140 61 192*
Total 26,737 26,737 5,234 13,403* 26,737 26,737 5,189 14,496* 4,549 10,144 317 2,192* 9,230 7,185 490 3,344*
a

The classification of the relative expression of hybrids (H) compared to their parental inbred lines (HP, high parent; LP, low parent) is based on the three pairwise tests listed in the Criteria columns (N, no; Y, yes).  bNonadditively expressed genes were determined relative to their midparent value.  cExpected (E) values were calculated as (number of nonadditive genes in B73×Mo17 × number of nonadditive genes in Mo17×B73)/number of all expressed genes. The number of all expressed genes is the sum of classes 1 to 9. C, Control; O, observed; WD, water deficit. The numbers of expected and observed overlapping genes were compared using a χ2 test. Significant values are indicated by asterisks: P ≤ 0.01.