Table 3.
The DVF 90 percentile error for IC Demons, SIFT, and Canny DIR methods at 0° and 40° using various DIR methods scenarios for all noise contamination levels. Noise level 1, 2, and 3, correspond to standard deviations of 2.3%, 4.6%, and 11.59% respectively, of the maximum signal intensity.
| No Noise | noise level 1 | noise level 2 | noise level 3 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||||||||
| 0° | 40° | 0° | 40° | 0° | 40° | 0° | 40° | ||
| zone 1 | IC Demons 90% error (μm) | 240.3 | 618.7 | 255.9 | 691.1 | 295.1 | 754.2 | 511.1 | 801.1 |
| SIFT 90% error (μm) | 291.4 | 503.4 | 300.1 | 551.1 | 361.9 | 602.1 | 410.2 | 690.0 | |
| Canny DIR 90% error (μm) | 258.2 | 395.5 | 259.8 | 403.2 | 272.1 | 457.4 | 301.0 | 540.1 | |
|
| |||||||||
| zone 2 | IC Demons 90% error (μm) | 248.1 | 781.8 | 272.6 | 779.3 | 342.2 | 784.1 | 522.1 | 815.0 |
| SIFT 90% error (μm) | 279.7 | 566.2 | 281.2 | 591.8 | 301.9 | 653.8 | 367.2 | 699.9 | |
| Canny DIR 90% error (μm) | 251.2 | 442.1 | 250.2 | 459.4 | 283.9 | 483.5 | 283.9 | 501.3 | |
|
| |||||||||
| zone 3 | IC Demons 90% error (μm) | 234.8 | 738.6 | 240.1 | 792.7 | 369.1 | 806.1 | 561.7 | 810.1 |
| SIFT 90% error (μm) | 269.6 | 703.1 | 272.2 | 762.3 | 347.1 | 792.6 | 407.6 | 808.7 | |
| Canny DIR 90% error (μm) | 259.3 | 569.0 | 260.5 | 581.2 | 290.1 | 604.2 | 367.2 | 637.6 | |
|
| |||||||||
| zone 4 | IC Demons 90% error (μm) | 221.8 | 807.7 | 241.7 | 801.9 | 391.7 | 810.4 | 581.1 | 809.2 |
| SIFT 90% error (μm) | 304.5 | 758.8 | 321.2 | 771.2 | 376.2 | 790.0 | 431.9 | 810.9 | |
| Canny DIR 90% error (μm) | 232.2 | 631.9 | 236.1 | 657.2 | 298.9 | 701.9 | 389.1 | 742.8 | |