Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 6;12(2):e0171652. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0171652

Table 2. Description of included records.

Coding Category Characteristic Frequency Percentage
Category (n = 84) Academic Literature 53 63.1
Grey Literature 31 36.9
Theme (n = 84) Biomechanical efficacy 50 59.5
Clinical effectiveness 20 23.8
Workplace safety 17 20.2
Cost-effectiveness 12 14.3
Primarily focused on compliant flooring findings (n = 84) 67 79.8
Source of literature (n = 84) Record from original academic search 51 60.7
MEDLINE 21 41.2
Web of Science 11 21.6
CINAHL 9 17.6
AgeLine 7 13.7
Ergo-Abs 1 2.0
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 1 2.0
SportDiscus 1 2.0
Record from experts 17 20.2
Record from conference 8 9.5
Record from reference list 5 6.0
Record from academic search post-baseline 2 2.4
MEDLINE 1 50.0
Web of Science 1 50.0
Record from website 1 1.2
Record from Proquest Thesis/Dissertation search 0 0.0
Record from clinical trial registries 0 0.0
Record from Age Ageing table of contents 0 0.0
Journal Category (n = 53) Engineering, other 13 24.5
Engineering, biomedical 10 18.9
Geriatrics and gerontology 9 17.0
Public, environmental, and occupational health 9 17.0
Rehabilitation 6 11.3
Nursing 4 7.5
Orthopaedics 2 3.8
Non-English Record (n = 84) 1 1.2
Type of Record (n = 84) Original article 49 58.3
Conference abstract/proceeding 13 15.5
Non-systematic review 6 7.1
Report 5 6.0
Thesis/dissertation 5 6.0
Book/book chapter 2 2.4
Editorial/opinion piece 2 2.4
Periodical 1 1.2
Clinical trial registration 1 1.2
Primary Study Design (n = 86)* Controlled experiment 51 59.3
Simulation study 11 12.8
Non-systematic review 7 8.1
Randomized control trial 3 3.5
Opinion piece 2 2.3
Retrospective cohort study 2 2.3
Non-randomized controlled trial 2 2.3
Report 1 1.2
Survey 1 1.2
Longitudinal comparative cohort study 1 1.2
Qualitative Methods 1 1.2
Prospective cohort study 1 1.2
Longitudinal observational study 1 1.2
Not applicable 2 2.3
Country of origin (n = 85) United States 34 40.0
Canada 18 21.2
United Kingdom 14 16.5
Sweden 6 7.1
New Zealand 5 5.9
Japan 3 3.5
Australia 3 3.5
Brazil 1 1.2
Netherlands 1 1.2
Setting (n = 84) Laboratory 15 17.9
Hospital/acute care 14 16.7
Long-term care/nursing home 10 11.9
Community 2 2.4
Other 4 4.8
Not reported/no setting 39 46.4
Population (n = 96) Older adults (65+ years) 34 35.4
Adults (18–64 years) 24 25.0
Special populations 10 10.4
Not reported 5 5.2
Not applicable 23 24.0
Decade of Publication (n = 84) 1980–1989 3 3.6
1990–1999 16 19.0
2000–2009 26 31.0
2010–2016 39 46.4

Notes. Numbers may be higher than 84 records as each record can span multiple categories.

* 3 studies used both controlled experiment and modelling study designs.

1 study took place in nursing homes across the United Kingdom and Australia.

Other study settings include assisted living (1), hospice (1), industrial setting (1), and conference center (1).