Table 2. Hypotheses to explain the need for mineral mobilization in titanosaurs and how they cope with the evidence from Lo Hueco.
Hypothesis short-name | Low-density bone origin hypothesis | Predictions | Evidence-support |
---|---|---|---|
Pneumatic hypothesis | The low density bone of the osteoderms would be a by product of a pneumatization of the bone. | Bone similar to camellate bone. | N - the anatomical architecture of both types of bone is different. |
Seasonal-changes hypothesis | The large hollow spaces of the osteoderms would result from mineral mobilization as an adaptation to extreme seasonal changes. | If the assemblage occured in an extremely seasonal environment, a majority of osteoderms should present large hollow spaces or signs of mineral mobilization (heavy remodeling and evidence of past hollow spaces) | N - osteoderms with low density bone are <50% of the sample which comes from an extremely seasonal environment. Past hollow spaces have not been identified either. |
Aging hypothesis | The low density bone of the osteoderms would appear as a result of decalcification in older individuals. | Osteoderms with large internal hollow spaces associated with senescent individuals. | N - An osteoderm associated with large internal hollow spaces associated with a non senescent adult individual. |
Oogenesis hypothesis | The low-density bone of the osteoderms is the result of the need of calcium for the formation of eggshells during oogenesis. | i) Osteoderms would be the only readily source for minerals in a titanosaur. ii) Osteoderms of comparable sizes (attributable to adult reproductive female and male titanosaurs) both compact and hollow. iii) Not a larger number of osteoderms with large hollow spaces (<50%), that is, those belonging to females in reproductive age. | Y - i) Osteoderms of comparable size classes from the same stratigraphic horizon are both hollow and compact. ii) A minority of osteoderms (3/10) have low density bone. |
See discussion for a more in depth description of the hypotheses. Y = yes. N = no.