Table 4.
Advantages | Drawbacks | Robustness for large scale analysis | Exemples of use | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pre-analysis labelling (A single analysis (sample combination after labelling): mass difference between peptide pairs on the same mass spectra) |
In vitro/vivo labelling (during protein synthesis) | 15N, 13C, | Accuracy | Limited to cells in culture,time-consuming | Yes (regardless of the cost and time needed) |
Cells in culture |
SILAC, CIDTs, superSILAC, SILAM | ||||||
Pre-digestion labelling | ICPL, iTRAQ, TMT, ICAT, ALICE, dimethyl | Sample complexity | Low sequence recovery | All types of biological sample (regardless of the protein quantity needed) | ||
In-digestion labelling | H218O | Simplified signal analysis, low cost | Late labelling | |||
Post-digestion labelling | ICAT, iTRAQ, ICPL, ALICE, TMT | High sequence recovery | ||||
dimethyl, GIST | ||||||
Direct analysis (Two (or more) analyses carried out independently before their comparison) | Label-free Quantification (without internal standard) | Comparison of mass spectra | Sample number, low cost | Separations normalisation, signal alignment | Yes | All types of biological sample |
Spectral counting | ||||||
Absolute Quantification (with internal standard) | AQUA | Easy to use | Cost of internal standard, analysis of one or few proteins | No(too expensive) | Validation of biomarkers | |
QconCAT | Enzymatic digestion take into account | |||||
PSAQ | ||||||
SRM / MRM | High sensitivity and reproducibility |
a SILAC, stable isotope labelling by amino acids in cell culture; CDIT, culture-derived isotope tags; SILAM, stable isotope labelling of mammal; ICPL, isotope-coded protein label; TMT, tandem mass tags; ICAT, isotope-coded affinity tags; iTRAQ, isobaric tags for relative and absolute quantification; ALICE, acid-labile isotope-coded extractants; GIST, global internal standard technology; Coomassie brilliant blue; XIC, extracted ion chromatogram; AQUA, absolute quantification of proteins; QconCAT, absolute quantification using artificial proteins of concatenated signature peptides; PSAQ, protein standard for absolute quantification; IMAC, immobilised metal affinity chromatography.