Skip to main content
. 2016 Jun 3;264(2):211–220. doi: 10.1007/s00415-016-8170-8

Table 3.

Methodological features of the validation studies

Study Screening test Reference Assessor of reference test Assessor of screening test Cut-off for screening test Blindinga Consecutive inclusion
Al-Khawaja 1996 [13] FAST SLT SLT Non-specialist, n.f.s. 17b; 16c; 15d (short) n.r. No
Enderby 1987 [14] FAST SLT, FCP, sS SLT n.r. 23 (full); 14 (short) n.r. n.r.
O’Neill 1990 [15] FAST sS, BDAE SLT Physician 25 n.r. Yes
Flamand-Roze 2011 [21] LAST BDAE n.r SLT, nurse, neurologist, or student 15 Yes, n.f.s. No
Choi 2015 [18] MAST* Physiatrist Physiatrist Research assistant, test scored by SLT 16j; 14k n.r. No
Kostalova 2008 [16] MAST SLT SLT Neurology resident and student 93e; 96f; 98g n.r. No
Romero 2012 [17] MAST BDAE, TT Clinical expert, n.f.s. Clinical expert, SLT, neurologist 90 No No
Doesborgh 2003 [20] ScreeLing TT, exp. Neurologist, linguist n.r. 66 Yes, 3 Yes
Al-Khawaja 1996 [13] SST SLT SLT Non-specialist, n.f.s. 17h; 16i; 15d n.r. No
Kim 2011 [22] SVF STAND n.r. n.r. 60 s; 7/30 s; 6 n.r. No
Thommessen 1999 [19] UAS SLT, parts of NGA SLT Nurse n.r. Yes, 2 Yes

SLT speech and language therapist, FCP functional communication profile, sS short Schuell, BDAE Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination, TT Token Test, exp. expert assessment, NGA Norsk grunntest for afasi (Norwegian Basic Aphasia Assessment), TAND Screening Test for Aphasia and Neurologic-Communication Disorders, n.f.s. not further specified, n.r. not reported

aBlinding: 1 for reference test only, 2 for screening test only, 3 for reference and screening test

bFor age ≤59 years

cFor age 60–70 years

dFor age ≥71 years

eFor age ≤60 years

fFor age 61–70 years

gBasic and secondary education

hAcademic education, age ≥60 years

iAcademic education, age <60 years

jFor age ≤64 years

kFor age >64 years