Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 14;12(2):e0171635. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0171635

Table 5. Univariate and multivariate analyses of clinical symptoms in the minimal hearing loss group compared to the normal hearing group.

Classifications Frequency Weighted Frequency Weighted Percent (%) Univariable analysis Multivariable analysis
P-value OR 95% CI P-value OR 95% CI
Subjective hearing loss
Total
not discomfort 14,245 31,889,494 93 - - - - - -
discomfort 1,324 2,393,253 7
Normal hearing (ref)
not discomfort 8,243 20,255,980 96.9 ref ref ref ref ref ref
discomfort 268 652,917 3.1
Minimal hearing loss
not discomfort 6,002 11,633,514 87 < 0.0001* 4.641 3.901–5.522 < 0.0001* 2.729 2.217–3.360
discomfort (event) 1,056 1,740,336 13
USHL
not discomfort 2,178 4,515,893 90.2 < 0.0001* 3.388 1.599–2.119 < 0.0001* 2.484 1.815–3.400
discomfort (event) 265 493,123 9.8
  Slight USHL
not discomfort 1,796 3,729,636 93 < 0.0001* 2.339 1.258–1.859 0.0168* 1.61 1.059–2.447
discomfort (event) 153 281,149 7
  Mild to profound USHL
not discomfort 382 786,257 78.8 < 0.0001* 8.365 2.266–3.692 < 0.0001* 6.556 3.904–11.010
discomfort (event) 112 211,974 21.2
BSHL
not discomfort 2,738 4,672,983 81.6 < 0.0001* 6.98 2.360–2.957 < 0.0001* 3.781 2.768–5.166
discomfort (event) 688 1,051,318 18.4
  Minimal BSHL
not discomfort 1,625 2,923,129 87.9 < 0.0001* 4.254 1.782–2.388 < 0.0001* 2.687 1.782–4.051
discomfort (event) 243 400,770 12.1
  Mild BSHL
not discomfort 1,113 1,749,854 72.9 < 0.0001* 11.534 2.957–3.901 < 0.0001* 6.352 4.229–9.540
discomfort (event) 445 650,548 27.1
HFSHL
not discomfort 1,086 2,444,638 92.6 < 0.0001* 2.486 1.316–1.889 0.0141* 1.732 1.090–2.752
discomfort (event) 103 195,895 7.4
  Unilateral HFSHL
not discomfort 466 1,004,601 88.9 < 0.0001* 3.878 1.529–2.537 < 0.0001* 2.499 1.351–4.622
discomfort (event) 62 125,562 11.1
  Bilateral HFSHL
not discomfort 620 1,440,037 95.3 0.3012 1.515 0.931–1.628 1.000 1.089 0.563–2.108
discomfort (event) 41 70,333 4.7
Presence of tinnitus
Total
yes 3,120 6,679,347 19.5 - - - - - -
no 12,449 27,603,399 80.5
Normal hearing (ref)
yes 1,435 3,616,316 17.3 ref ref ref ref ref ref
no 7,076 17,292,580 82.7
Minimal hearing loss
yes (event) 1,685 3,063,031 22.9 < 0.0001* 1.421 1.275–1.583 < 0.0001* 1.520 1.333–1.734
no 5,373 10,310,819 77.1
USHL
yes (event) 527 1,065,106 21.3 0.0018* 1.291 1.040–1.242 < 0.0001* 1.460 1.199–1.776
no 1,916 3,943,910 78.7
  Slight USHL
yes (event) 393 798,167 19.9 0.2598 1.188 0.974–1.219 0.0042* 1.376 1.075–1.762
no 1,556 3,212,618 80.1
  Mild to profound USHL
yes (event) 134 266,939 26.7 0.0002* 1.745 1.108–1.575 < 0.0001* 2.010 1.388–2.912
no 360 731,292 73.3
BSHL
yes (event) 906 1,462,309 25.5 < 0.0001* 1.641 1.184–1.386 < 0.0001* 1.939 1.580–2.378
no 2,520 4,261,991 74.5
  Minimal BSHL
yes (event) 490 756,671 31.5 0.0216* 1.289 1.012–1.273 < 0.0001* 1.637 1.260–2.126
no 1,068 1,643,731 68.5
  Mild BSHL
yes (event) 252 535,615 20.3 < 0.0001* 2.201 1.343–1.639 < 0.0001* 3.145 2.362–4.189
no 937 2,104,918 79.7
HFSHL
yes (event) 252 535,615 20.3 0.1653 1.217 0.976–1.246 < 0.0001* 1.871 1.402–2.496
no 937 2,104,918 79.7
  Unilateral HFSHL
yes (event) 115 227,892 20.2 1 1.208 0.914–1.322 < 0.0001* 2.006 1.315–3.060
no 413 902,271 79.8
  Bilateral HFSHL
yes (event) 137 307,723 20.4 0.7446 1.224 0.931–1.315 0.0004* 1.784 1.224–2.600
no 524 1,202,647 79.6
Presence of annoying tinnitus
Total
yes 14,688 32,548,170 94.9 - - - - - -
no 881 1,734,576 5.1
Normal hearing (ref)
yes 8,225 20,231,329 96.8 ref ref ref ref ref ref
no 286 677,568 3.2
Minimal hearing loss
yes (event) 6,463 12,316,841 92.1 < 0.0001* 2.562 2.129–3.083 < 0.0001* 1.868 1.511–2.310
no 595 1,057,008 7.9
USHL
yes (event) 2,266 4,650,684 92.8 < 0.0001* 2.301 1.308–1.759 < 0.0001* 1.946 1.413–2.680
no 177 358,332 7.2
  Slight USHL
yes (event) 1,833 3,781,937 94.3 0.0002* 1.807 1.117–1.618 0.0186* 1.545 1.050–2.274
no 116 228,848 5.7
  Mild to profound USHL
yes (event) 433 868,748 87 < 0.0001* 4.45 1.626–2.736 < 0.0001* 3.906 2.277–6.701
no 61 129,484 13
BSHL
yes (event) 3,080 5,174,162 90.4 < 0.0001* 3.175 1.568–2.025 < 0.0001* 2.099 1.5523–2.894
no 346 550,139 9.6
  Minimal BSHL
yes (event) 1,735 3,103,064 93.4 < 0.0001* 2.125 1.205–1.764 0.0210* 1.589 1.048–2.410
no 133 220,834 6.6
  Mild BSHL
yes (event) 1,345 2,071,097 86.3 < 0.0001* 4.748 1.869–2.541 < 0.0001* 3.618 2.213–5.915
no 213 329,305 13.7
HFSHL
yes (event) 1,117 2,491,995 94.4 0.0018* 1.78 1.093–1.629 0.00451* 1.952 1.183–3.2219
no 72 148,538 5.6
  Unilateral HFSHL
yes (event) 491 1,069,736 94.7 0.0774 1.687 0.985–1.712 0.162 1.734 0.901–3.336
no 37 60,427 5.3
  Bilateral HFSHL
yes (event) 626 1,422,260 94.2 0.0324* 1.85 1.018–1.818 0.0288* 2.032 1.049–3.935
no 35 88,111 5.8
Classifications Frequency Weighted Frequency Average Univariable analysis Multivariable analysis
P-value P-value
EQ-5D index
Total 13,730 29,912,914 0.956 - -
Normal hearing (ref) 6,906 17,066,487 0.972 ref ref
Minimal hearing loss 6,824 12,846,427 0.935 < 0.0001* < 0.0001*
USHL 2,311 4,716,951 0.949 < 0.0001* 0.0024*
  Slight USHL 1,850 3,785,067 0.949 < 0.0001* 0.0078*
  Mild to profound USHL 461 931,884 0.95 0.0001* 1.000
BSHL 3,348 5,558,945 0.911 < 0.0001* < 0.0001*
  Minimal BSHL 1,868 3,323,898 0.926 < 0.0001* < 0.0001*
  Mild BSHL 1558 2,400,402 0.889 < 0.0001* < 0.0001*
HFSHL 1,165 2,570,532 0.962 0.0084* 0.936
  Unilateral HFSHL 520 1,099,964 0.961 0.168 1.000
  Bilateral HFSHL 645 1,470,568 0.962 0.1752 1.000

Multivariate analysis adjusted for age and sex. An asterisk (*) indicates a significant difference (P < 0.05).

USHL, unilateral sensorineural hearing loss; BSHL, bilateral sensorineural hearing loss; HFSHL, high-frequency sensorineural hearing loss; CI, confidence interval; OR, odds ratio