Table 1.
Characteristics of the included studies
| Ref. | Age (years old) | Length of follow-up (years) | Diagnosis | Cementing technique (generation) | Comparison | Approach | Comments | |
| Bjørgul et al[11] | 65 to 66 | 14 | Osteoarthritis (most) | 3rd | Cemented (n = 120) | Hybrid (n = 120) | direct lateral | |
| Chandran et al[12] | 64.5 to 65.5 | 14 | primary Osteoarthritis | 2nd | Cemented (n = 97) | Cementless (n = 105) | anterolateral | |
| Corten et al[13] | 64 (mean) | 19.5 | primary Osteoarthritis | 2nd | Cemented (n = 124) | Cementless (n = 126) | direct lateral | |
| Kim et al[14] | 43.4 to 46.8 | 18.4 | Avascular necrosis (most) | 3rd | Hybrid (n = 109) | Cementless (n = 110) | ND | May overlap with Kim et al[15] |
| McCombe et al[16] | 67.3 | 6.5 to 8 | Primary OA (most) | 2nd | Cemented (n = 84) | Hybric (n = 78) | posterolateral | |
| Berend et al[17] | 67.1 | 6.8 | Osteoarthritis (most) | ND | Cemented (n = 1908) | Cementless (n = 623) | anterolateral and posterior | |
| Clohisy et al[18] | 61 to 62 | 10 to 11 | Osteoarthritis | 2nd | Cemented (n = 45) | Hybrid (n = 45) | posterolateral | |
| Emerson et al[8] | 55 to 70 | 6.7 to 7.2 | Osteoarthritis (most) | 3rd | Hybrid (n = 113) | Cementless (n = 88) | anterolateral | |
| Hartofilakidis et al[19] | 39.6 to 45.4 | 12.4 to 15.4 | Osteoarthrosis secondary to congenital hip disease (most) | 2nd | Cemented (n = 59) | Hybric (n = 58) | lateral transtrochanteric | |
| Kim et al[15] | 64.6 | 17.3 | Avascular necrosis | 3rd | Hybrid (n = 50) | Cementless (n = 98) | ND | May overlap with et al[14] |
| Pospula et al[20] | 46.7 to 53.7 | 3 to 5 | Avascular necrosis (most) | ND | Cemented (n = 87) | Cementless (n = 95) | cemented posterolateral cementless transgluteal | |
| Van Stralen et al[21] | 69.5 | 2.5 | Primary OA (most) | Cemented (n = 746) | Cementless (n = 138) | posterior | ||
| Thomason et al[22] | 54 | 7.4 | Rheumatoid arthritis | ND | Hybrid (n = 47) | Cementless (n = 51) | posterior | |
| Zimmerman et al[7] | 74.9 | 1 | Osteoarthritis | ND | Hybrid (n = 85) | Cementless (n = 174) | anterolateral, posterior | |
| Conroy et al[23] | Any | 5 | Osteoarthritis | ND | Cemented (n = 8945); hybrid (n = 20445); | ND | ||
| Cementless (n = 28582) | ||||||||
| Dale et al[24] | Any | 0 to 20 | Osteoarthritis (most) | ND | Cemented (n = 82996) | Cementless (n = 14348) | ND | May overlap with study of et al[16] |
| Engesaeter et al[25] | Any | 0 to 16 | Primary Osteoarthritis | ND | Cemented (n = 51016) | Cementless (n = 5259) | ND | May overlap with et al[15] |
| Eskelinen et al[26] | < 55 | 0 to 24 | Rheumatoid arthritis | ND | Cemented (n = 821) | Cementless (n = 724) | ND | |
| Hailer et al[27] | Any | 15 | Osteoarthritis (most) | ND | Cemented (n = 161460) | Cementless (n = 8593) | ND | |
| Hooper et al[28] | Any | 7 | ND | ND | Cemented (n = 16005); hybrid (n = 15189) | ND | ||
| Cementless (n = 10898) | ||||||||
| Lucht et al[29] | Any | 4 | ND | Cemented (n = 11671); hybric (n = 4491) | ND | |||
| Cementless (n = 2030) | ||||||||
| Mäkelä et al[30] | > 55 | 15 | Osteoarthritis | ND | Cemented (n = 9549) | Cementless (n = 10310) | ND | |
| Mäkelä et al[31] | 63 to 69 (> 55) | 15 | Rheumatoid arthritis | ND | Cemented (n = 3440) | Cementless (n = 579) | ND | |
| Mäkelä et al[32] | < 55 | 15 | Osteoarthritis | ND | Cemented (n = 2342) | Cementless (n = 1326) | ND | |
| Malchau et al[33] | All | 8 | Osteoarthritis (most) | ND | Cemented (n = 178762) | Cementless (n = 6102) | ND | |
| Pedersen et al[34] | Any | 0 to 14 | Osteoarthritis (most) | ND | Cemented (n = 34656); cementless (n = 25571) | ND | ||
| Hybrid (n = 20539) | ||||||||
| Roberts et al[35] | All | ND | ND | ND | Cemented (n = 92928) | Cementless (n = 69882) | ND | |