Table 4.
First author, year | Country/Study design | Samples | Mean BMI | Obesity measures | Measures | ACE in BED | Variables predicted OB/BED | Results |
Allison, 2007 | USA CC |
N = 271 (204 ♀) BED = 176 (139 ♀) NES = 57 (41 ♀) OB = 38 (24 ♀) Age of BED = 44.9 |
BED = 35.6 | LM BMI | CTQ EDE SCID-I/P |
Tot ACE = 82% CEA = 54% CPA = 31% CSA = 29% CEN = 69% CPN = 50% |
Tot ACE + in BED/NES CEA + in BED/NES CN + in BED No differences in BMI |
|
Becker, 2011 | USA CS |
N = 137 ♀ BED Age = 43.9 |
35.7 | LM BMI OB = BMI ≥ 30 |
CTQ SCID-I/P EDE |
CEA = 71 CPA = 38 CSA = 42 CN = 156 |
OB onset = CPA | |
Dalle Grave, 1997 | Italy CC |
N = 64 ♀ OB BED = 29 OB = 35 Age = 36.4 |
N = 35.7 BED = 35.0 OB = 36.3 |
LM BMI OB = BMI > 30 |
Clinical Standardized Interview for Trauma Semistructured Interview for BED diagnosis |
ACE in OB = 26% ACE in OB/BED = 41.3% |
ACE + in OB-BED | |
Gabert, 2013 | Canada CS |
N = 500 M-OB (441 ♀) BED = 148 Age = 43.7 |
47.9 | LM BMI M-OB = BMI ≥ 35 |
Interview about CSA | CSA in ♀ = 23.6% CSA in ♂ = 8.5% |
BED + in CSA CSA = non CSA in BMI |
|
Grilo, 2001 | USA CC |
BED = 145 (111 ♀) OB/BED = 105 NS = 1125 ♀ Age BED = 43.6 |
BED = 37.9 | LM BMI OB = BMI ≥ 30 |
CTQ SCID-I EDE-Q CPA = 35.8% QEWP-R |
Any ACE = 82.8% CEA = 59.3% CPA = 35.8% CSA = 30.3% CEN = 69% CPN = 48.6% |
OB/BED = BED in any ACE BED > NS in Any ACE |
|
Grilo, 2002 | USA CC |
BED = 116 (90 ♀) NS = 1125 ♀ Age BED = 44.2 Age NS = 42 |
CTQ SCID-I |
Any ACE = 81.9% CEA = 52.6% CPA = 31.9% CSA = 25.9% CEN = 67.2% CPN = 49.6% |
BED > NS in Any ACE | |||
Knoph Berg, 2011 | Norway CS |
N = 45644 ♀ BED = 931 Age = 29.9 |
SR BMI | 2 questions about CPA 2 questions about CSA Diagnostic algorithms based on DSM-IV for BED At least 1 binge per week |
CPA in BED = 23.6% CSA in BED = 24.0% |
BED = CSA, CPA | ||
Mitchell, 2012 | USA CS |
N = 5692 (3310 ♀) BED = 105 (75 ♀) Age ♂ = 43.2 Age ♀ = 44.0 |
CIDI | Any ACE = 90.3% Any Int-ACE = 63.7% R = 19.5% CSA = 34.8% CPA = 13.71% DV = 30.8% Stalking = 33.8% |
Any ACE + in BED Any Int-ACE + in BED CSA + in BED R + in ♂ BED CPA + in BED DV + in BED Stalking + in BED |
|||
Pike, 2006 | USA CC |
BED = 162 ♀ (101 OB) CG = 162 ♀ (32 OB) PC = 107 ♀ (23 OB) Age BED = 30.8 Age CG = 30.0 Age PC = 20.5 |
BED = 34.6 NC = 25.6 PC = 25.9 |
LM BMI OB = BMI ≥ 30 |
RFI SCID-IV Abbreviated version of EDE |
CSA = 8.6% CPA = 16.7% NC = 42.9% |
BED = > 3 ACE | CSA + in BED CPA + in BED NC + in BED |
Striegel-Moore, 2002 | USA CC |
BED = 162 ♀ CG = 251 ♀ Age BED = 30 Age CG = 30 |
Oxford assessment | CSA = 56.7% CPA = 65% B = 46.7% |
CSA + in BED CPA + in BED B + in BED |
Index: EDE = Eating Disorder Examination; CTQ = Childhood Trauma Questionnaire; SCID-I/P = Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV-TR Axis I Disorders Patient edition; SCID-I = Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV-TR Axis I Disorders; SCID-IV = Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV-TR Disorders; ACE = Adverse Childhood Experiences; CSA = Childhood Sexual Abuse; CPA = Childhood Physical Abuse; CN = Childhood Neglect; CEA = Childhood Emotional Abuse; DV = Domestic violence; B = Bullied/rejected; R = rape; NC = Negative comments in family about shape and weight; BED = Binge Eating Disorder; BEB = Binge Eating Behaviors; M-OB = Morbid obese; OB = Obese; BMI = Body Mass Index (kg/m2); SR BMI = Self-reported BMI; LM BMI = Laboratory measure of BMI; WC = Waist Circumference (cm); QEWP-R = Questionnaire of Eating and Weight Patterns-Revised; CIDI = World Health Organization Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI) for DSM-IV and ICD-10 diagnosis; RFI = Oxford Risk Factor Interview.