Table 2. Studies reporting the sensitivity of an MND code in routinely collected datasets, separated by dataset evaluated.
First author | Country | Study period | Study population used to generate reference standard | Study size (n) | Routine dataset | Coding system | Code(s) assessed | Coding position assessed | Disease investigated | Sensitivity summary | Notable study characteristics |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chancellor 19937 | UK | 1989–1990 | MND cases as listed on the Scottish Motor Neurone Disease Register (SMNDR) | 317 | H | ICD-9 | 335 | Any | MND | Proportion of MND cases with ICD-9 discharge code 335.2 | |
Chió 20028 | Italy | 1995–1996 | ALS cases as listed on The Piemonte and Valle d’Aosta Register for ALS (PARALS)) | 213 | H | ICD-9 | 335.2 | Any | ALS | Proportion of ALS cases with ICD-9 discharge code 335.2 | Analysis limited to incident cases |
Chancellor 19937 | UK | 1989–1990 | Deceased Scottish Motor Neurone Disease Register (SMNDR) cases. | 95 | D | ICD-9 | 335 | Any | MND | Proportion of death certificates of known MND cases that report MND | |
Chió 199217 | Italy | 1970–1985 | Deceased ALS cases ascertained from multiple overlapping sources (hospital archives, neurophysiology laboratories, social security records and files of neurologists) | 488 | D | Unclear | Unclear | Primary | ALS | Proportion of death certificates of known ALS cases that report ALS | |
Yeo 201016 | Republic of Ireland | 2002–2006 | Deceased cases registered with the Irish Register for ALS/MND | 398 | D | ICD-9 | Unclear | Any | ALS/MND | Proportion of death certificates of known ALS/MND cases that report ALS/MND |
Study population: Source of cases including method of case ascertainment. Study size: Number of known MND cases for which a code was sought. Routine dataset: The routinely collected source of coded datasets; H: hospital admissions data, D: death certification. MND codes: ICD-9 & ICD-9-CM: 335.2 = MND, 335.20 = amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, 335.21 = progressive muscular atrophy, 335.22 = progressive bulbar palsy, 335.23 = pseudobulbar palsy, 335.24 = primary lateral sclerosis, 335.29 = other motor neurone disease. ICD-10: G12.2 = MND, G12.20 = unspecified, G12.21 = amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, G12.22 = progressive bulbar palsy, G12.29 = other motor neurone disease. Coding position: Position at which a code for MND was assessed in the major analysis in the study.