Table 2.
Subtype | Treatment | Study Population | Design | Study | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Immune paralysis |
Immune suppressant Withdrawal |
Case reports |
Infection and MODS resolution |
||
GM-CSF 66,118,120 | Children with ≥ 3 organ failure and ex vivo TNF response < 168 pg/mL; N = 14; GM-CSF N =7, Standard N = 7 |
Randomized Controlled Trial |
Prospective Single Center66 |
GM-CSF reversed immune paralysis, and reduced the onset of nosocomial infection from 8 infections in 7 patients with placebo patients with GM-CSF (p < 0.05). |
|
Adults with septic shock/severe sepsis/MODS and Immune paralysis defined by low monocyte HLA-DR expression N = 38; GM-CSF N = 19, placebo N = 19 |
Randomized Placebo Controlled Trial |
Prospective Multiple Center Study118 |
GM-CSF reversed immune paralysis, increased ventilator free days and improved Physiologic Severity/MODS Score (p < 0.05). |
||
Interferon gamma154 |
Intubated adults with severe multiple trauma and immune paralysis N=21; Inhaled Interferon gamma N = 11, Inhaled placebo N = 10 |
Randomized Placebo Controlled Trial |
Prospective Single Center Study154 |
Inhaled Interferon gamma reduced ventilator associated pneumonia (p< 0.5) and restored alveolar macrophage HLA-DR expression |
|
Thrombocytopenia Associated MOF |
Plasma Exchange 30,31,48,49,155 |
Pediatric TAMOF N =42 15 plasma exchange; 27 standard care |
Cohort Study Plasma Exchange vs Standard Therapy |
Prospective Multiple Center Analysis49 |
28 day Mortality decreased from 70.4% to 26.7%; Multivariate analysis found improved survival controlling for PRISM, OFI, PELOD, neurologic failure (p = 0.048). |
Pediatric TAMOF N=10; plasma exchange N = 5; standard therapy N = 5 |
Randomized Controlled Trial Plasma Exchange vs Standard Therapy |
Prospective Single Center30 |
Plasma exchange restored organ function, improved ADAMTS13 levels, and reduced 28 day mortality from 80% to 0% (p < 0.05) |
||
Adult TAMOF N = 37; Plasma infusion N = 22, Plasma exchange N = 15 |
Randomized Trial Plasma Infusion Vs Plasma Exchange |
Prospective Single Center155 |
Plasma exchange reduced hospital mortality from 32% to 0% (p < 0.001) |
||
Adult TAMOF N=102; Plasma infusion N = 51, Plasma Exchange N = 51 |
Randomized Trial Plasma Infusion vs Plasma Exchange |
Prospective Multiple Center31 |
Plasma exchange Reduced hospital mortality from 16% to 4% (p = 0.035); and 6 month mortality from 37% to 22% (p = 0.035) |
||
C5a antibody (Ecullizumab)42–47 |
Two small Phase II trials; age > 12 years with atypical Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome |
Open Label Single Arm; Year Long Treatment |
Prospective Multiple Center42 |
Improved renal function over time and loss of plasma exchange dependence led to FDA approval as orphan drug |
|
Case series N=3 of children with HUS- STEC-related MODS treated with plasma exchange/ Eculizumab rescue |
Open Label Single Arm Two Week Treatment |
Retro- spective Single Center Case Series47 |
Improved MODS resolution and renal function thought to be temporally related to Eculizumab |
||
Sequential MOF | Rituximab156,157 | Phase II trial of N = 43 adults with PTLD unresponsive to holding immune suppression subsequently treated with Rituximab |
Open Label Single Arm |
Prospective Multiple Center Study156 |
86% survival at 80 days; 62% survival at 1 year |
Phase II trial of adding Rituximab to low dose chemotherapy N = 55 in children with PTLD already receiving low dose cytoxan and prednisone |
Open Label Single Arm |
Prospective Multiple Center Study157 |
83% survival at 4.8 years |
||
Antivirals/IVIG/ Methylprednisone |
Case reports |
Infection and MODS resolution |
|||
HLH protocol158 | Case series treated with HLH-94 protocol |
Registry, Open label Single Arm |
Retro- spective, Multiple Center158 |
5 year probability of survival is 54% |
|
Macrophage Activation Syndrome |
Methylprednisone/ IVIG / Plasma Exchange69 |
Pediatric secondary hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis /sepsis/multiple organ dysfunction syndrome/macro- phage activation syndrome N = 23; HLH chemotherapy protocol N =6, IVIG / Methylprednisone N = 17 |
Cluster Randomized Trial Comparing HLH Protocol With Plasma Exchange To IVIG/ Methyl- Prednisone With Plasma Exchange |
Prospective Multiple Center Analysis69 |
Plasma exchange and treatment with IVIG/Methyl- prednisone reduced hospital mortality from 50% to 0% (p = 0.002). |
IRAP70,159 | Adult MODS with disseminated intravascular coagulation and hepatobiliary dysfunction |
Randomized Double Blinded Placebo Controlled Trial |
Post Hoc Multiple Center Analysis159 |
28 day mortality decreased from 64.7% to 34.6% hazard ratio 0.28 [95% Confidence Interval I 0.11–0.0071] p = 0.007 |
|
Pediatric secondary hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis /sepsis/multiple organ dysfunction syndrome/macro- phage activation syndrome treated with IRAP N=8 |
Case series | Post-Hoc Single Center70 |
Considered to be temporally related to improvement of MODS. Hospital survival 100%. |
||
Tocilizumab71,160 | Pediatric patients with cytokine releasing syndrome after CART treated with tocilizumab N = 13 |
Case series | Post-Hoc Single Center160 |
Considered to be temporally related to improvement of MODS |
MODS- Multiple Organ Dysfunction Syndrome, GM-CSF- Granulocyte Macrophage Colony Stimulating Factor, N – number of patients, HLA-DR – Human leukocyte antigen DR, TAMOF – Thrombocytopenia associated Multiple Organ Failure, PRISM – Pediatric Risk of Mortality, OFI – Organ Failure Index, C5a – Complement component 5a, HUS-STEC – Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome-Shiga Toxin producing Escherichia Coli, FDA – Food and Drug Administration, PTLD – Post Transplant Lympho Proliferative Disease, IVIG – Intra Venous Immune Globulin , HLH – Hemophagocytic Lympho Histiocytosis, IRAP – Interleukin 1 receptor antagonist protein, CART – Chimeric Antigen Receptor T cell therapy