Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 2;12(3):e0173155. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0173155

Table 1. Number of E. coli, total and antibiotic resistant coliforms.

        No. of E. coli strains (MPN/100ml)     Bacterial count on L-TTC +/- antibiotics (CFU/mL)
Site Point of sampling Geographic coordinates Land use around sampling point Nb of sampling Mean Number Min—max L-TTC L-TTC + AMP L-TTC + CAZ L-TTC + CIP
            Mean number Min—max Mean number (%) Min—max Mean number (%) Min—max Mean number Min—max
1 WWTP Influent 16°20'02"N 61°42'04"W 6 2.38 x 107 6.01 x 105–8.20 x 107 6.80 x 108 2.52 x 107–2.38 x 109 3.4 x 108 (50.00) 1.50 x 107–1.20 x 109 1.22 x 108 (17.9) 3.65 x 106–4.32 x 108 1.10 x 107 (1.6) 3.98 x 105–3.90 x 107
WWTP Effluent   6 7.62 x 105 4.01 x 104–2.17 x 106 9.00 x 107 4.15 x 106–3.26 x 108 4.8 x 107 (53.3) 4.25 x 106–1.68 x 108 2.10 x 107 (23.3) 8.30 x 105 -7.07 x 107 1.00 x 106 (1.1) 3.80 x 104–3.70 x 106
Point 1 16°17'29''N 61°43'44"W Broad-leaved forest 2 0 0.00 3.61 x 104 1.27 x 104–5.95 x 104 9.20 x 103 (25.5) 5.60 x 103–1.28 x 104 3.45 x 102 (1.1) 1.10 x 102–3.90 x 102 40.00 (0.1) 20.00–60.00
Point 2 16°18'16"N 61°43'23"W 2 7.50 0.00–15 1.07 x 104 6.50 x 103–1.4 9x 104 5.00 x 103 (46.7) 2.42 x 103–7.58 x 103 1.00 x 103 (9.3) 0–2.00 x 103 0.00 (0.0) 0.00
Point 3 16°18'55"N 61°43'17"W 2 63.50 0.00 -127 2.60 x 104 2.00 x 104–3.20 x 104 1.84 x 104 (70.8) 1.22 x 104–1.84 x 104 2.10 x 103 (8.2) 1.10 x 103–3.10 x 103 0.00 (0.0) 0.00
Point 4 16°19'38"N 61°42'11"W Urban area/Crops 2 2.42 x 102 1.60 x 102–3.24 x 102 4.40 x 104 8.00 x 103–8.00 x 104 3.08 x 104 (70.00) 2.70 x 104–3.84 x 104 2.30 x 103 (5.4) 5.00 x 102–4.10 x 103 40.00 (0.09) 0–80
Point 5 16°19'47"N 61°42'14"W 2 9.08 x 103 8.32 x 103–9.83 x 103 1.40 x 105 8.00 x 104 -2.00 x 105 3.92 x 104 (35.7) 3.84 x 104–4.00 x 104 3.10 x 104 (22.2) 2.90 x 104–3.30 x 104 2.20 x 103 (1.6) 1.50 x 103–3.00 x 103
Point 6 16°19'54''N 61°42'14''W 6 2.30 x 105 2.45 x 104–3.99 x 105 8.50 x 105 2.25 x 104–2.30 x 106 7.10 x 105 (83.7) 4.00 x 105–1.60 x 106 3.98 x 105 (46.00) 5.90 x 104–1.31 x 106 1.38 x 105 (16.1) 1.6 x 104–2.00 x 105
Point 7 16°20'07''N 61°42'15''W Discharge 6 9.26 x 105 8.55 x 104–4.01 x 106 2.70 x 106 3.10 x 105–1.70 x 107 2.28 x 106 (84.4) 3.60 x 105–4.00 x 106 6.40 x 105 (23.6) 1.60 x 105–1.37 x 106 3.82 x 105(14.0) 2.00 x 104–8.00 x 105
Point 8 16°20'06"N 61°42'03"W Mangrove 6 8.68 x 103 1.35 x 103–4.09 x 104 2.85 x 105 5.70 x 104–1.70 x 106 2.70 x 105 (94.7) 1.00 x 103–3.80 x 105 2.25 x 105 (78.9) 1.60 x 104–6.20 x 105 2.40 x 104 (8.4) 9.30 x 103–5.30 x 104
Point 9 16°20'15"N 61°42'02"W Open sea 6 1.88 x 103 0–6.39 x 103 5.75 x 104 1.30 x 104–2.70 x 105 2.60 x 104 (45.2) 4.00 x 102–4.00 x 104 2.60 x 103 (4.5) 1.00 x 102–5.50 x 103 4.50 x 102 (0.8) 0.00–1.3 x 103
2 WWTP Influent 16°14'15"N 61°33'49"W 3 1.21 x 107 8.93 x 106–1.76 x 107 4.00 x 108 2.03 x 108–7.41 x 108 2.30 x 108 (57.5) 1.52 x 108 _ 3.85 x 108 6.2 x 107 (15.5) 3.80 x 107–1.02 x 108 7.70 x 106 (1.9) 3.75 x 106–1.50 x 107
WWTP Effluent   3 3.93 x 105 1.34 x 105–8.42 x 105 5.80 x 107 3.58 x 107–8.54 x 107 2.30 x 107 (39.6) 1.52 x 107–3.49 x 107 5.2 x 105 (9.00) 4.32 x 105 _ 6.16 x 105 4.00 x 105 (0.7) 2.35 x 105–5.28 x 105
Point 1 16°13'39"N 61°33'43" W Discharge 6 14.1 <15–30 7.00 x 102 3.00 x 102–9.00 x 102 5.00 x 102 (71.4) 20.00–2.00 x 103 62.00 (8.8) 20.00–1.00 x 102 1.00 x 102 (14.3) 0.00–6.70 x 102
Point 2 16°14'07"N 61°34'00"W Broad-leaved forest 6 10 <15 7.30 x103 3.00 x 102–4.12 x 104 3.01 x 103 (42.4) 60.00–1.00 x 104 2.1 x 103 (28.8) 2.5 x 102–1.3 x 104 2.20 x 102 (3.00) 0.00–5.20 x 102
3 Point 1 16°16'51"N 61°33'10"W Mangrove 6 67 <15–3.47 x 102 1.10 x 103 3.00 x 102 -1.45 x 104 8.00 x 102 (72.7) 4.20 x 102–2.60 x 103 1.3 x 102 (11.8) 50.00–1.00 x 103 80.00 (7.3) 40.00–2.50 x 102
Point 2 16°16'41"N 61°33'15"W 6 24.33 < 15–61 6.30 x 103 3.50 x 103–2.60 x 104 1.60 x 103 (25.3) 3.00 x 102–5.00 x 103 8.1 x 102 (12.8) 1.70 x 102–2.00 x 103 1.70 x 102 (2.7) 40.00–6.00 x 102
4 Point 1 16°10'27''N 61°41'45"W Broad-leaved forest 2 0 0 8.00 x 103 6.00 x 103–10.00 x 103 4.98 x 103 (62.25) 1.00 x 103–8.96 x 103 6.2 x 102 (7.75) 1.00 x 102–9.40 x 102 0.00 (0.0) 0.00
Point 2 16°09'53''N 61°40'15"W 2 2.40 x 102 0–4.80 x 102 2.35 x 104 9.00 x 103–4.69 x 104 1.78 x 104 (76.2) 5.60 x 103–3.00 x 104 3.5 x 103 (14.9) 1.70 x 103–5.30 x 103 0.00 (0.0) 0.00
Point 3 16°12'16"N 61°39'13"W Urban area/Crops 2 4.52 x 103 0–9.04 x 103 6.05 x 104 2.10 x 104–1.00 x 105 4.05 x 104 (66.9) 4.00 x 104–4.50 x 104 1.37 x 104 (22.6) 1.14 x 104–1.6 x 104 50.00 (0.16) 0.00–1.00 x 102
Point 4 16°13'54"N 61°40'11"W 2 93.5 30–1.27 x 102 6.00 x 104 2.00 x 104–1.00 x 105 4.15 x 104 (69.2) 3.50 x 103–4.80 x 104 1.68 x 104 (28.0) 3.00 x 103–3.33 x 104 0.00 (0.0) 0.00
Point 5 16°16'09"N 61°40'18"W 2 1.81 x 102 46–2.70 7.00 x 104 3.00 x 104–1.10 x 105 5.00 x 104 (71.4) 2.00 x 104–8.00 x 104 4.45 x 103 (15.7) 3.40 x 103–5.50 x 103 1.00 x 102 (0.14) 26.00–1.74 x 102
Point 6 16°17'23"N 61°39'36"W 2 2.10 x 102 93–2.34 x 102 7.00 x 104 6.00 x 104–8.00 x 104 5.00 x 104 (71.4) 4.00 x 104–5.00 x 104 5.00 x 103 (7.1) 3.90 x 103–6.10 x 103 3.36 x 102 (4.8) 1.70 x 102–5.02 x 102

WWTP, waste water treatment plants; MPN, most probable number; CFU, colony-forming unit; Selective growth media: TTC Triphenyltetrazolium Chloride; AMP, ampicillin; CAZ, ceftazidime; CIP, ciprofloxacin